It's a huge decision and I applaud you for thinking with your head as well as your heart. I know if I just followed my heart, I would have 100+ cats!
As others have said, I think starting out as a foster would be an excellent option for Clementine (LOVE that name, BTW). See how things go. You would be in a better position to see how well the three would get along.
Something you said in your original post has stuck with me..
I have always chosen to bring a cat into our family by asking "Does this cat need ME?" Of the cats we have, there was always an inner voice giving a loud, "YES".
It's usually a little bit later that I discover that yes, I did need another cat.
Good luck to you and Clementine, whatever you decide!
As others have said, I think starting out as a foster would be an excellent option for Clementine (LOVE that name, BTW). See how things go. You would be in a better position to see how well the three would get along.
Something you said in your original post has stuck with me..
...
I don’t need another cat, I don’t need another cat, I don’t need another cat...
I have always chosen to bring a cat into our family by asking "Does this cat need ME?" Of the cats we have, there was always an inner voice giving a loud, "YES".
It's usually a little bit later that I discover that yes, I did need another cat.
Good luck to you and Clementine, whatever you decide!