Tippy Toes: Map to buried treasure or of the world for a sea faring adventure
Morgana: Diamonds
Liffey: Mice
Everyone else: Temptations cat treats
All my guys have gotten really good at getting the whole lizard. Probably 75% of them even still have tails, which could be commentary on our local lizards survival instincts. Most of the lizards I see are even still alive and manage to survive the play session.