Yes, ditch the dry food entirely! If at all possible, transition her to human-grade canned food or raw. Feed-grade canned food or kibble are very bad for cats' long-term health. With animal health, it's either pay now or pay later. Trust me; you'd be a whole lot better off paying more with higher quality food now if at all possible, rather than go years and years investing in the cheap stuff and suddenly you have a cat suffering and requiring very expensive medical treatment.Thanks everybody. You've convinced me.
As long as she's enjoying the Fancy Feast wet I will limit her dry food even more. I suppose it would be ideal to stop feeding it to her at all, right?