I really love this resource to get information on all the cat food brands. http://catfooddb.com
However, I looked at their section on Top 12 dry and top 12 wet cat foods—updated 2018. There were some glaring inconsistencies with what they stated as criteria and what they listed as the top foods. For the wet food they very clearly stated all were either 9 or 10 paws but their #10 pick was of all things Purina One grain free classic turkey with 5 paws! The ingredients certainly aren’t bad but no way is this a top 10 wet food out of the hundreds they cover. And for the dry, they clearly state that “freeze dried” would be eliminated for this ranking but #1 and #2 were freeze dried as was #6 and #7. Those things tend to make me question the reliability of the reviews. But regardless, it is a useful site.
However, I looked at their section on Top 12 dry and top 12 wet cat foods—updated 2018. There were some glaring inconsistencies with what they stated as criteria and what they listed as the top foods. For the wet food they very clearly stated all were either 9 or 10 paws but their #10 pick was of all things Purina One grain free classic turkey with 5 paws! The ingredients certainly aren’t bad but no way is this a top 10 wet food out of the hundreds they cover. And for the dry, they clearly state that “freeze dried” would be eliminated for this ranking but #1 and #2 were freeze dried as was #6 and #7. Those things tend to make me question the reliability of the reviews. But regardless, it is a useful site.