Me too! There are so many cute cuddly toys but Gypsy won't have anything to do with them. She loves cardboard scratchers.The toy thing depends on the cat.
Sweet Gum's reaction to toys as a kitten was she adored little balls of foil to chase. She took her big cuddle doll (stuffed rabbit) and used it to block the door on her carrier when we went to the vet. That was it.
She has a long piece of clothesline she likes to chase. If you try this make the clothesline move like a snake.
But other than the above, she will not touch a new toy until it's been in the toy box or on the floor near the toy box for 9 months. Then she'll play with it. The only trick is to wait and see what the pattern is. Yes, I was disappointed she didn't want cuddly toys.