Elsey’s, Epigen, or Instinct? Allergy cat... canned suggestions welcome too!

[Harborlily]

My 10 yr old tuxedo boy is an itchy scratchy stomach churning allergy cat. We have never been able to pinpoint the exact allergy, he does well on the Natural Balance LID dry but hates the wet, and vital essentials freeze dried patties.

I have a 2 yr old fat tuxedo boy too.

What I do now is: Fussie Cat Market Fresh chicken and turkey dry with a sprinkle of vital essentials turkey patty and spring water. But I’m not a fan of the fussie cat ingredients and I would like it to be healthier, and the younger one hates fussie cat and the vital essentials .

So out of those three what would be the tastiest and the healthiest? I’m leaning towards Elseys...

Also any relatively cheap healthy cans? He can’t have meat by product at all so friskier and fancy feast etc are out..

 

[molly92]

Dr. Elsey's would probably be my pick for dry too.

As long as you don't think chicken is the allergen, Whole Earth Farms is a decent canned food for a decent price. Not as cheap as Fancy Feast, but no by-products either and they don't over do it on the carbs.