My cat was being fed Beyond cat food, Fancy Feast wet food. He LOVES gravy, But lately he only smells it, he might lick but never eats it. He uses the towel to cover the wet food with his paws. I had mashed potatoes with gravy and he licked the entire lid. Not sure whether the cat food had gravy or not recently but he Loves Meow Mix chicken flavor and all of his TEMPTATION Cat Treats.