I may disguise my order as "needing more cat litter and had to get over $49 for free shipping..." 
-
Too many ads? Join our community of cat lovers now to reduce ads by 90%! Click here to join for free!
What Is The Next New Cat Food You Want To Try?
- Thread starter duckpond
- Start Date
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2019
- Messages
- 24
- Purraise
- 21
I've heard Tiny Tiger is great, especially their Whitefish and Tuna. Maybe you can order a sample size and convince him to order more if your cat(s) like it?I want to try American Journey and Tiny Tiger from Chewy while they still have their awesome sale going on but I fear DH may divorce me if I order more cat food...
But I feel you. I got INORDINATELY excited about finding out that Bosie's favourite food (meaning the only one he eats, bless his heart) is available in 28oz cans too now. My fiancé just looked at me blankly.
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2018
- Messages
- 280
- Purraise
- 464
I feel your pain with the "too much cat food" ordering!I want to try American Journey and Tiny Tiger from Chewy while they still have their awesome sale going on but I fear DH may divorce me if I order more cat food...
Sorry, but establishing a good feeding routine (including WHAT to feed) is of utmost importance in this house!! HAHA. Lately it seems like I am the only one excited about trying new foods. My cats just stare at me or walk away.
I am waiting for an order of Tiny Tiger from Chewy right now actually. I am hoping that they like it. I am trying to chunks in gravy multi-flavor pack to start. The price is amazing and it's grain-free so that is a huge plus. All 4 cats have to like it or its a no-go. Food jealousy makes it impossible to feed different foods to different cats in our house.
All the reviews on Chewy are either "my cat freaking LOVES this stuff! 15/10 stars" or "my cat thinks I'm trying to kill her, -5/10 stars". Very interesting....
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2018
- Messages
- 280
- Purraise
- 464
I think that is fairly common with cat food in general right?! I try foods all the time that got mostly 5/5 stars and "picky cats love this" reviews and then my cats hate it and hate me for trying it!
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2018
- Messages
- 438
- Purraise
- 406
I just bought a can of Taste of the Wild....venison, for my two to try out.
That's us with Dr. Elsey's dry. My cat didn't get the memo about how it's all the rage
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2018
- Messages
- 280
- Purraise
- 464
See mine really seem to enjoy one or two flavors of the Fancy Feast Classic Pate line, and they like fish flavors on their own, BUT the chicken pate fancy feast seems to have too much fish mixed in with the chicken. It smells awfully fishy compared to other flavors. I am hoping that they like Tiny Tiger because fish seems to be slightly lower on the ingredient list. Also, FYI the chunks in gravy kinds don't have fish except the beef flavor!
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2018
- Messages
- 280
- Purraise
- 464
Oh and another plus with cats is they seem to over hear me talking to my girlfriend about nasty ingredients and things we want to try and avoid (i.e. carrageenan).
So now whenever I try to buy a cat food that does not contain these "evil" ingredients, they don't like it. When I buy Blue Buffalo they devour it and could not care less about the ingredients label!
So now whenever I try to buy a cat food that does not contain these "evil" ingredients, they don't like it. When I buy Blue Buffalo they devour it and could not care less about the ingredients label!
She won't eat any of the chunks of any brand. Just to be extra difficult
Otherwise I would definitely give them a shot!
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2018
- Messages
- 236
- Purraise
- 178
I really glad my cats aren’t picky. The only food they dislike was taste of the wild canned as the Pate was really dry. They have allergies. But a pet store 16 miles away is cheaper on their wet food. So I get it there.
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2018
- Messages
- 280
- Purraise
- 464
You are lucky!
I have 4 young cats and I am actually a relatively new cat owner in general. We have been playing a chess match to decide what foods they actually like! It is not enjoyable at all, picky cats are pretty much just regular cats in my eyes
- Joined
- Jul 14, 2018
- Messages
- 303
- Purraise
- 374
You got that right! Cat = pickypicky cats are pretty much just regular cats in my eyes
Got my samples from Rawz today...Evie and Emerson liked it ok, Dexter spent 5 minutes trying to bury it...
Austin is supposed to be on SO food, and it turns out that is the only food he'll even think about eating. At least he eats the canned.
Cricket is another fuss budget, she'll only eat Weruva cats in the kitchen Mack, Jack, and Skip and Chick Magnet. And dry food, which I pretty much have to give her because she only has a few licks of the wet stuff (even if I don't put dry down).
Cricket is another fuss budget, she'll only eat Weruva cats in the kitchen Mack, Jack, and Skip and Chick Magnet. And dry food, which I pretty much have to give her because she only has a few licks of the wet stuff (even if I don't put dry down).
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2018
- Messages
- 280
- Purraise
- 464
I feel like a cat burying their food before even eating it is the cat equivalent to giving the middle fingerGot my samples from Rawz today...Evie and Emerson liked it ok, Dexter spent 5 minutes trying to bury it...
I feel like a cat burying their food before even eating it is the cat equivalent to giving the middle finger
In his defense he did eat some of it! He usually tries to bury any food he eats, regardless of what it is, but only for a second or two. After about the 50th scratch I hollered at him to knock it off...lol
- Joined
- Oct 31, 2018
- Messages
- 280
- Purraise
- 464
Oh BELIEVE ME I know what it looks like!! My Otis does the same thing with food if he does not like it! Just last week he was burying his food, then taking another bite, then burying it again for like 5 minutes straight. It's like he knows how much time I invest in finding food for him and he teases me for it! Here's a visual aid for you:
He is BEAUTIFUL!
