Welcome to The Cat Site
your cat community
Interact with our community
  1. Hi Guest! Cat experts Esther Mechler (founder of Spay USA) and Dr. Phil Bushby, DVM will be here from August 13th through 15th.
    Visit this time-limited forum here and post your questions about spaying and neutering cats.

Wellness Needs To Seriously Address Whether Their Foods Contribute To Flutd

Discussion in 'Cat Nutrition' started by Azazel, May 15, 2018.

  1. Azazel

    Azazel Thread Starter TCS Member Alpha Cat

    687
    858
    Apr 14, 2018
    New York, NY
    I have now heard way too many anecdotal stories about cats being on Wellness and developing urinary issues. One of my own kittens a long time ago also developed crystals while on Wellness canned food. They went away as soon as I switched the brand.

    I know this is anectodal and it could just be a coincidental relationship between wellness and urinary infections but I seriously think there is something in their foods that upsets normal ph balance and contributes to urinary issues.

    Thoughts?
     

  2. abyeb

    abyeb Charlie's Purrson Staff Member Forum Helper

    5,827
    6,855
    Feb 18, 2017
    I couldn’t find a lot of info about this on TCS, post #32 on this thread says that Wellness isn’t recommended for cats with urinary issues, but again, this isn’t a result from an official study: Publix brand cat food..
     

  3. maggie101

    maggie101 3 cats Super Cat

    922
    1,018
    Apr 20, 2014
    Houston,TX
    Proof? Articles I have read about it online are old
     

  4. white shadow

    white shadow TCS Member Top Cat

    1,256
    585
    Nov 28, 2010
    CA
    @Azazel - I have to say that I found the thread title somewhat alarming.......

    Now, I came to the online cat community in 2007 when we were literally traumatized by a seemingly never-ending daily rollout of announcements of food recalls.....cats were being poisoned by the thousands in a mysterious epidemic that no one could initially explain. People would awake every morning and immediately go to known authoritative sites (like TCS) to see if the food they used had appeared on a recall list overnight - it was a never-ending nightmare. And, this continued for months !

    To this day, one of the first things I do every day is to scan for anything similar.......which is how I just found this thread and why I'm reacting as I am.

    Now, as @abyeb said, there is only one vague reference to this (urinary) issue here on TCS - ONE - and, if anyone reads that (plus the two subsequent posts, #33 & 34) the "issue" seems to disappear into thin air.....becomes a non-issue/concern.

    It just happens that I have been using Wellness canned ("Complete") regularly and almost exclusively for six male cats since April 2007 - eleven years.......without seeing, nor hearing, nor experiencing any such issue, nor any other threatening issue. There was only one possible issue (with a potential thiamine deficiency) in one variety, I think, about 3 years ago - which Wellness announced 'loudly' and widely and dealt with immediately.

    I don't mean nor want in any way to diminish the effect that your kitten's experience had on you - even though it was "a long time ago", I'm sure it still resonates with you - it would with me.
    .
     
    Lari purraised this.

  5. maggie101

    maggie101 3 cats Super Cat

    922
    1,018
    Apr 20, 2014
    Houston,TX
    How do I get to the post? That is an old post
     

  6. Azazel

    Azazel Thread Starter TCS Member Alpha Cat

    687
    858
    Apr 14, 2018
    New York, NY
    Just to clarify - I'm not saying that I have proof or that Wellness food causes urinary issues. I'm just saying that I've heard of it being linked to crystals time and time again. You can see it on many review sites and there are other posts on this website discussing it.

    Here are a few more that I found and I only looked through the first 2 of 10 pages that came up in my search.

    Kitty had struvite crystals...diet help?!>

    Wet food for cat after UTI/crystals

    Best Canned Food for cats prone to Urinary Blockage/Crystals

    Not trying to alarm anyone, but since there's been so much speculation I really do wonder if some Wellness varieties alter ph level to encourage crystal formation.
     

  7. catlover73

    catlover73 TCS Member Top Cat

    2,348
    1,004
    Sep 3, 2006
    Chicago area
    I used to feed Wellness Core Original dry food. One of my cats got a Urinary Blockage and had to be hospitalized for 3 days in ICU. His blockage was actually caused by a UTI that got bad very quickly and not any type of crystals. He had an ultrasound to check for crystals. While he was in the hospital I did some research on dry cat foods. I came across too many reviews in too many different places mentioning urinary issues with the Wellness Core I was feeding. My adult cats will not eat enough wet food to make it their only food source long term. I did do a wet food diet while I was searching for a new dry food after Sonny came home from the vet. I switched my dry food from Wellness Core to Farmina Lamb and Blueberry Formula. I had been wanting to do a food change any way because one of my other cats was over grooming his belly to the point of fur loss. My vet did not find anything that resembled skin issues. There was no rash and no itching. He was acting normal other than over-grooming. I switched foods and the protein source. The over-grooming has stopped. His fur is growing back normally on his belly now. I have an independent pet food store in my area that I go to when i am doing food changes. The staff knows a lot about food and has done their own research. They also mentioned that their customers were mentioning more urinary issues with the Wellness Dry food. They were working with customers to transitions their cats to other dry foods. They were also thinking of stopping carrying the Wellness Core Dry food if it was going to become a health issue. I do now buy my cat food online because while this pet food place is great for getting help with food changes their prices are too high to buy my food there all the time for 4 cats.
     

  8. maggie101

    maggie101 3 cats Super Cat

    922
    1,018
    Apr 20, 2014
    Houston,TX
    This is what Dr. Lisa,DVM wrote about it
    Hi Guys,

    Too tired to type much....plus my fingers are really done for the day....

    I spent over an hour on VIN searching for posts on this issue....did not find anything significant. That said, I spoke with a colleague about a year ago who swears up and down that she sees more blocked cats on Wellness but I really don't know if she had pinned down canned or dry. She "thinks" some of the cats blocked even when on canned but not all vets are good at detailed history taking....so who knows.....

    This is not the first time this has come up - it has been discussed on the internet for the past couple of years but I am thoroughly perplexed by it AND....there are just never enough details for me to come to any conclusions. Most of the time dry food is being fed, or they state "canned and dry" with no idea of of the proportion of each.

    I have scrutinized the mineral data for all of the Wellness foods and, if anything, they are lower in struvite building blocks (magnesium and phosphorus) than a lot of other diets so I have no clue as to why cats would end up blocked when on canned Wellness.

    Another very important issue that I stress on my Urinary Tract Health page is....how were the "crystals" diagnosed? Via a send-out test (worthless and inaccurate with a lot of false positives)....or....within ~20 minutes of the urine leaving the bladder?

    Urine = 102 degrees when inside the cat. Urine = ~70 degrees in a vet hospital. Crystals form in cold urine.

    Another issue....Wellness has been listed on my Commercial Canned Food page for 9 years yet I have not had a single person write to me about any issues with crystals. My website gets ~1.7 million visitors per year which generates ~20,000 emails per year.

    Bottom line: I add a lot of water to my cats' food no matter what I feed.
     
    Lari and Azazel purraised this.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.