No Excuse

kai bengals

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 5, 2005
Messages
3,931
Purraise
17
Location
North Carolina
A bengal breeder posted on one of the lists I belong to that she has bengal/munchkin kitten mixes for sale.

Says it was an unplanned breeding and for the rest of us not to get mad about it. Yeah right. Then don't advertise.


This sort of thing really burns me. Next thing you know someone will
think it's cool to have stunted little dwarf leopards as pets. I've seen the pics of her bengal/munchkin kittens......it's sad. Especially when you know how active the bengal breed is.

This brings to mind the thread from a week ago about catteries breeding several different breed cats and whether it can be done properly.

This is what can happen when it goes wrong.
 

familytimerags

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
976
Purraise
4
Location
Yukon, OK
We have Bengal/Ragdoll mixes and Ragdoll/Munchkin Ragdolls that are being purposely bred. You and I agree, there isn't an excuse, but as we both see within breeding, this isn't always the case. Breeders are not all created equal, and neither are all cats within the breed, there are breeders that won't breed Bengals to type, and some who won't breed Ragdolls to type. If there was some way I could think to fix the problem, I would be first on the list. It seems the only thing the states want to do is force mandatory spay and neuters bills, that only shut down the hobby breeder, not the one who is large and commercialized, and breeds for profit.

So now we have short Bengals and Ragdolls, and now Ragdolls come in polka dotted, sounds funny, but I can imagine neither of our lauging.
 

sharky

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
27,233
Purraise
35
URGGHHH....

I was at the vet with Gigi and a guy s bulldog ( 2yrs and not fixed) mated with a boxer ... he was beside himself about them not being pure and had no clue about whelping or puppies( a friend let the other dog in the yard)
 

missymotus

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
May 8, 2005
Messages
9,038
Purraise
49
I don't understand why they would advertise that. My sister had an exotic/oriental from an oops litter and the breeder (a friend of theirs) wanted to keep it all hushed up, placed the kittens quietly.
 

familytimerags

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
976
Purraise
4
Location
Yukon, OK
Originally Posted by missymotus

I don't understand why they would advertise that. My sister had an exotic/oriental from an oops litter and the breeder (a friend of theirs) wanted to keep it all hushed up, placed the kittens quietly.
The difference seems to be that your sister's friend had an accident, those do happen, the person Nial is speaking of is purposely mixing Bengals and Munchkins. There are some "breeders" who will mix breeds and begin calling them new names, it has became a huge fad with dogs, and it seems that breeding cats and creating a mixed breed from 2 pedigreed cats, is something many are doing. I don't agree with it, but most of these people have their minds already made up, and don't wish to change that opinion.
 

abymummy

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
4,074
Purraise
11
Location
Malaysia
IMO ... there is no reason to breed Bengals to Munchkins eventhough registered breeders here in Malaysia do so
Their "reason" is to get the Bengal glitter/markings and pelt quality onto the short legs of munchkins. Of course, they use unregistered bengals to do so
Lemme find a pic and post it later ...


But then, some "breeders" also bred Munchkins to Persians to create the Napoleans ... so where do YOU draw the line?
 

familytimerags

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
976
Purraise
4
Location
Yukon, OK
Originally Posted by Abymummy

IMO ... there is no reason to breed Bengals to Munchkins eventhough registered breeders here in Malaysia do so
Their "reason" is to get the Bengal glitter/markings and pelt quality onto the short legs of munchkins. Of course, they use unregistered bengals to do so
Lemme find a pic and post it later ...


But then, some "breeders" also bred Munchkins to Persians to create the Napoleans ... so where do YOU draw the line?
I had a woman a few months back contact me for a "munchkin" Ragdoll. I explained there was no such Ragdoll, she pointed me to a site, that was mixing the breeds. IMO, it was cruel. Those of you who show realize a Ragdoll is a larger breed, a longer body structure, ect. I can't begin to imagine the back problems, and other health issues from the mixing these breeds.
A good question, where does one draw the line? What does one find acceptable and unacceptable? There are cat fancy breeds that I disagree with, but still those who responsibly breed these breeds.
Of course my chosen breed is still a relatively young breed, man made by an eccentric woman, (to say the least), if it wasn't for what we would call BYB experiences, the Ragdoll breed wouldn't exist, however it was introduced into the cat fancy and out of this has came a very popular, attractive, type cat with wonderful traits.
So do we call those who experiment with creating a new breed, eccentric, and when they accept it into the cat fancy, one feels this is now a good thing, but for those who experiment and fail, are these considered different breeders. A very difficult subject for me, I wouldn't say I was on the fence. I am not for any newer so called designer cats, however, I am not sure I can criticize if someone is really trying to create something different, in type, trait, and with good record keeping is able to create something.
I think this is a subject that could have many answers and opinions. I still however, don't feel those just putting 2 purebred cats together is doing anything positive for any breed, unless accepted outcross, and that outcross should still be health checked within a few generations back.
 

siggav

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 26, 2007
Messages
1,327
Purraise
22
Location
Scotland
I'm personally against all cat mutations and breeds that make a cat divert greatly from the basic "cat" shape. Cats are absolutely a fantastic design of a creature and they can't really be improved and shouldn't be messed around with on a fundamental level.

I'm not talking about breeding for type because changing face structure, coat, eye colour etc. as long as it's not extreme doesn't change the basic functional operation of the cats body.

So there's no surprise I don't like Munchkin cats and I wish the breed hadn't been created. I don't really like Manx cats or Scottish folds either. Same goes for the most extreme perisans and siamese, although to a lesser degree, since their extreme face structure can adversely affect the cat but very good breeders can keep type and health however there are a lot of bad ones out there that don't and the cats suffer.

So yeah me being appalled at bengals being bred to munchkins on purpose is not an understatement.

I've been called a hypocrite having that opinion and then loving bengals but I'm not against breeding or man made breeds as long as the outcome is a healthy, athletic "cat shaped" cat. Which Bengals are, Ragdolls too for that matter.
 

miyu

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
Mar 28, 2007
Messages
101
Purraise
0
Yes, it its huge in the dogs, I just donâ€[emoji]8482[/emoji]t get it, getting a dog mixed with another is just as good as getting the pure thing. Like my friend just got a puppy that is half chewawa and half wiener dog( donâ€[emoji]8482[/emoji]t know how to spell it) but it is retarded, I mean I donâ€[emoji]8482[/emoji]t agree, but he seems healthy and they love him, so I would never say anything.. oi... but I donâ€[emoji]8482[/emoji]t know... there are so many mixed animals out there, and many are really really healthy, but i have to agree, you really donâ€[emoji]8482[/emoji]t know what you are doing if you are mixing random cats that are so different from each other. Oiiiiii
 

goldenkitty45

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Aug 29, 2005
Messages
19,900
Purraise
39
Location
SW Minnesota
Don't get me started on the designer dogs.........


As long as someone out there finds a person to buy a designer dog or cat or whatever, they will breed them. Makes me mad and sick. We do our best to educate people but its an uphill climb; especially when it involves our own breed that we've worked so hard to produce good and healthy examples....to be ruined by backyard breeders (or unethical purebred breeders - like Nial mentioned).

I'm glad I am not the only one against some of the breeds - I don't like the munchkins either. While it might have been a mutation - it doesn't mean the mutation should be bred to create more. Cats are supposed to have longer legs to jump and run. IMO neither muchkins or doxies and others with extreme short legs should have been created. Doxies have so many back problems because of the way they are built. Munchkins will be next (with the back problems).
 

kitytize

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 21, 2005
Messages
2,155
Purraise
2
I would be upset over it too if people were mixing Somalis. Breeders work so hard to improve the breed and all it takes is one person to mess it up.
 

hopehacker

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 6, 2003
Messages
8,149
Purraise
4
Location
Los Angeles,CA
I would be very curious to see what a Munchkin/Bengal cross would look like. I do think it would greatly detract from the beauty of a Bengal, because half of the beauty of the Bengal is in the lithe body of the cat. They say a Munchkin is as healthy as any other cat, so I'm not going to talk against them. They're not my cup of tea, but I don't see why someone would try to create a Munchkin Bengal.

As far as Designer and EXTREME breeders, I'm totally against that, especially PERSIANS and what they've done to them. I had an extremely flat faced little Persian. His face was so flat, he couldn't enjoy wet food. He could only eat dry food. He tried to eat the wet, but his nose and mouth were so flat, he would almost drown trying to eat it. Persians originally had noses, and were beautiful just the way God made them. I don't know why breeders had to work until they created a totally peke faced Persian, where the cat looks grumpy and extremely jowely, and where they have breathing problems. It just doesn't make since to ruin a perfectly beautiful breed to fit some sort of standard. Same to some degree with Siamese. I do like the more modern wedge shaped Siamese, however they've gone to such an extreme that the Siamese they're breeding today look more like bats or Aliens than cats. Humans need to know when to STOP!
 

Anz

TCS Member
Kitten
Joined
May 16, 2021
Messages
1
Purraise
0
Im sorry.... but isnt the Ragdoll actually an Angora, Bred with a seal point Birman.... further cross bred with a Burmese. I don't see the Birman, Burmese and Angora Breeders going nuts abt that.

Cats are cats and I do HATE designer cats... but I have seen weird accidents in life. Do you know that in Dubai... 50% of the people who buy pure bread cats .. DO NOT WANT THEM SPAYED EVER.

I have seen Bengals bread with Angoras and ... the weirdest was a runt of Somalians bread with Russian Blues.. poor animals always looked like in a need of a bath... Siamese Bred with British Short hair so on and so forth.. Usually most of the liters actually do survive and are acceptable cats.

I know someone who actually had a breeding pair of bengals and Ragdolls.... Well guess what .... 6 months ago...there Bengal... just gave birth to 3 x fluffy tabbys and 2 Ragdolls... Yes its an accident... yes they Hushed it up like crazy... and were conscious not to sell the ragdolls at all and have spayed them and kept them. there Neighbours took the Blue Eyed Tabbys for their IT factor. Lets see if I see them turn out real weird.
 

Maurey

Maine Coon Madness
Super Cat
Joined
Jan 21, 2021
Messages
736
Purraise
829
Im sorry.... but isnt the Ragdoll actually an Angora, Bred with a seal point Birman.... further cross bred with a Burmese. I don't see the Birman, Burmese and Angora Breeders going nuts abt that.
There’s a difference between breed development, and designer breeds bred for profit by shady breeders. Ragdolls are all related to Josephine, the original domestic who started it all. Other breeds were brought in to aide Ragdoll conformation development and add genetic diversity.
 

sivyaleah

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Dec 16, 2011
Messages
5,281
Purraise
3,537
Location
New Jersey
Im sorry.... but isnt the Ragdoll actually an Angora, Bred with a seal point Birman.... further cross bred with a Burmese. I don't see the Birman, Burmese and Angora Breeders going nuts abt that.

Cats are cats and I do HATE designer cats... but I have seen weird accidents in life. Do you know that in Dubai... 50% of the people who buy pure bread cats .. DO NOT WANT THEM SPAYED EVER.

I have seen Bengals bread with Angoras and ... the weirdest was a runt of Somalians bread with Russian Blues.. poor animals always looked like in a need of a bath... Siamese Bred with British Short hair so on and so forth.. Usually most of the liters actually do survive and are acceptable cats.

I know someone who actually had a breeding pair of bengals and Ragdolls.... Well guess what .... 6 months ago...there Bengal... just gave birth to 3 x fluffy tabbys and 2 Ragdolls... Yes its an accident... yes they Hushed it up like crazy... and were conscious not to sell the ragdolls at all and have spayed them and kept them. there Neighbours took the Blue Eyed Tabbys for their IT factor. Lets see if I see them turn out real weird.
You are replying to a 14 year old thread.
 
Top