Hello all. I want to switch up my cats’ diets and I’m having some trouble finding a food they’ll ALL eat. Right now they eat dry food mixed with wet food, so I’ll need one of each. I don’t mind if it’s expensive but it can’t be too expensive, since I have nine cats to feed, and three are picky, but really they’re only picky with dry food.
They were originally on Meow Mix dry and Friskies wet (yuck I know, not my choice), and I tried out Canidae Limited Ingredient Chicken dry - and it was not a hit. They would eat it but they were not happy to. I then tried some Blue Buffalo dry and wet and they did devour the wet, but the three picky ones ignored the the dry food. I then tried Solid Gold Katz n Flocken and it was a huge hit ! But a normally not picky cat hated it, so I was back to square one. I recently tried Nulo cat and kitten cod flavor, and same thing happened as the Solid Gold - one cat refused to eat it, so she’s eating Meow Mix while everyone else eats Nulo.
Should I keep trying to find a food they’ll all like that isn’t garbage or should I buy two different day foods?
They were originally on Meow Mix dry and Friskies wet (yuck I know, not my choice), and I tried out Canidae Limited Ingredient Chicken dry - and it was not a hit. They would eat it but they were not happy to. I then tried some Blue Buffalo dry and wet and they did devour the wet, but the three picky ones ignored the the dry food. I then tried Solid Gold Katz n Flocken and it was a huge hit ! But a normally not picky cat hated it, so I was back to square one. I recently tried Nulo cat and kitten cod flavor, and same thing happened as the Solid Gold - one cat refused to eat it, so she’s eating Meow Mix while everyone else eats Nulo.
Should I keep trying to find a food they’ll all like that isn’t garbage or should I buy two different day foods?
). I think I’ll try a few more foods and if there’s still some resistance from them, I’ll just buy two different brands, I don’t mind doing it to keep them happy 
