My cat seems unhappy being indoors

Icecreamonster25

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
18
Purraise
23
Location
N/A
I recently brought my cat indoors after my other cat unexpectedly passed away in a car accident two weeks ago.

On day one, she seemed perfectly fine. On days two and three, I took her outside to the backyard in the morning after she woke up. She sniffed around and then came straight back inside on her own. Since then, we haven't let her go outside.

However, two weeks have passed, and it seems like she wants to go outside every night. Our family is not comfortable letting her out anymore, especially since my other cat's tragic accident happened right near our house. Every night, she stands at the back door and cries to go outside. We've gotten her a new cat tree, scratchers, toys, and a food puzzle, but she still doesn't seem happy. I play with her, turn on cat TV, and do other activities, but she doesn’t seem to enjoy them as much as being outside. I'm not sure what to do.

I feel guilty for not letting her out, especially since she has lived outdoors for five years. However, I'm also scared that if she goes out, something might happen like it did with my other cat, or that she will continuously ask to go outside.

I'm worried that if she remains indoors, she might become depressed or stressed. Would she? Am I making her unhappy by keeping her inside?

Also, if I ignore her desire to go outside, will she eventually stop crying and wanting to go out? Please help.
 

guarua

TCS Member
Young Cat
Joined
Oct 15, 2024
Messages
78
Purraise
112
Location
Massachusetts
It takes time, but she will get used to it. You're doing the right thing. My cat was an outdoor kitty many years ago, she would spend probably upwards of 10 hours outside, exploring and catching animals. We abruptly switched her to indoor only after there was a coyote sighting and she has been indoor ever since. For a long time she was very angry with us and would try to sneak out. But now she's happy to be an indoor cat and I'm very grateful I made the switch for her health, safety and the local ecosystem. She hasn't tried to sneak out in years but she is still an expert huntress and keeps us mouse-free!
Cats don't adjust to anything quickly, give it time, keep showing her what there is for her inside.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5

Icecreamonster25

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
18
Purraise
23
Location
N/A
Thank you all! I'm glad to hear that I'm doing the right thing. Hopefully she'll adjust to the indoor environment soon.

Also, just had a question. Would it be okay if I harness train her? or would it be better to just completely keep her indoors until she gets used to it? My dad said I should harness train her, so I can take her out walking just outside our house. What are your thoughts on this?
 

maggie101

3 cats
Top Cat
Joined
Apr 20, 2014
Messages
8,619
Purraise
11,604
Location
Houston,TX
Last edited:
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #7

Icecreamonster25

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
18
Purraise
23
Location
N/A

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
5,363
Purraise
12,667
Location
Victoria, Australia
Thank you all! I'm glad to hear that I'm doing the right thing. Hopefully she'll adjust to the indoor environment soon.

Also, just had a question. Would it be okay if I harness train her? or would it be better to just completely keep her indoors until she gets used to it? My dad said I should harness train her, so I can take her out walking just outside our house. What are your thoughts on this?
I harness trained the late Madeleine (my avatar) to harness when we moved to a granny flat in Queensland, which was much smaller than the 3-bedroom house we'd lived in. She adapted quite rapidly, and I would take her on walks around the property, or let her lie on the deck in her harness with the lead tied when I was sitting there with her. Phoebe and Daisy were another matter. Phoebe would lie around in her harness but didn't want to go for walks. Daisy doesn't like harnesses at all. The first one I tried she wriggled out of in a panic when we were just in my tiny courtyard and a leaf blew past. I bought a more secure one, but she hates the sound of the velcro fastener. I wish I could get her used to it - the exercise would do her good - but I don't think it's going to happen.
 

iPappy

TCS Member
Staff Member
Forum Helper
Joined
Jun 1, 2022
Messages
6,450
Purraise
20,753
I too think you're doing the right thing keeping her inside. Free roaming cats face a lot of dangers. I am so sorry about the loss of your other cat. :( Some friends of mine had a cat get outside and was only gone for an hour, but came back in with a huge, deep laceration on the top of his head that required an emergency vet trip and stitches. Thankfully, he's OK, but no one knows exactly what happened. So it's much safer to keep them indoors, or, like you mentioned, harness training which I think is a fantastic idea. It's become very popular in the past several years to do so and I personally know people who have done this, and their cats love being able to go outside and hang out on the deck or in the yard with their people.
I think training her to the harness now would be a good idea. Even if you keep her in and she forgets about going outside, odds are once she goes outside again that will all be forgotten. Just make sure the harness is properly fitted so that she can't back out of it if something should scare her (a loud noise, etc.)
Another idea would be a catio. You can do an internet image search for "catio ideas", they range from very small (almost like cat-sized window boxes) and simple, to very extravagant. My cats never took to harness training so I opted for a catio. They love their covered and cat-proof area to go outside whenever they please through a cat door.
 

maggie101

3 cats
Top Cat
Joined
Apr 20, 2014
Messages
8,619
Purraise
11,604
Location
Houston,TX
Ime it does take a while for them to adjust, but they will do so eventually. You're doing the right thing, keeping her safe from so many dangers and diseases (and keeping the local bird life safe from her).
My cat Coco used to be a stray. She devoured a blue jay,,except the feathers. Luckily she is afraid of the outdoors now
 

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
5,363
Purraise
12,667
Location
Victoria, Australia
My cat Coco used to be a stray. She devoured a blue jay,,except the feathers. Luckily she is afraid of the outdoors now
Sounds like my Katie - she was an indoor-outdoor cat most of her life and a dedicated bird hunter (I consoled myself that it was almost all introduced birds she got, blackbirds for the most part).
The only feral we had was Hadji, who Mum rescued as an abandoned month-old kitten from a colony. He never hunted anything except his toys. Birds would stroll right past him and he would take no notice of them!
 

maggie101

3 cats
Top Cat
Joined
Apr 20, 2014
Messages
8,619
Purraise
11,604
Location
Houston,TX
Sounds like my Katie - she was an indoor-outdoor cat most of her life and a dedicated bird hunter (I consoled myself that it was almost all introduced birds she got, blackbirds for the most part).
The only feral we had was Hadji, who Mum rescued as an abandoned month-old kitten from a colony. He never hunted anything except his toys. Birds would stroll right past him and he would take no notice of them!
I think it's because when Maggie was a stray kitten she only liked playing with bugs. Not old enough for hunting so I am guessing that her cat likes to hunt now
 
Last edited:

Alldara

TCS Member
Staff Member
Forum Helper
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
6,832
Purraise
12,401
Location
Canada
Thank you all! I'm glad to hear that I'm doing the right thing. Hopefully she'll adjust to the indoor environment soon.

Also, just had a question. Would it be okay if I harness train her? or would it be better to just completely keep her indoors until she gets used to it? My dad said I should harness train her, so I can take her out walking just outside our house. What are your thoughts on this?
That's up to you! I've had good luck with Magnus doing that. Keeping him on a schedule helps him to bug less about it.
 
Top