Feeling Hopeless: Should We Rehome Our Energetic Kitten After 5 Months?

leealandennis

TCS Member
Thread starter
Kitten
Joined
Jan 7, 2025
Messages
1
Purraise
1
Four to five months ago, we adopted a 7-month-old male kitten to be a friend for our 2-year-old resident female cat. Here's where we stand:

Behavior
He's a wonderful companion when alone, but his high energy leads to pouncing and rough play with our resident cat, resulting in fights. His intentions aren't malicious; he just wants to play, but she doesn't, leading to conflicts. Our resident cat is fine with him as long as he leaves her alone. Despite being charming with family and strangers, he won't leave our older cat alone when they're in the same room.

Behaviorist Intervention
We've been working with a cat behaviorist for 2-3 months, employing slow reintroduction techniques, including clicker training and controlled exposure through baby gates. Last night, we reached a significant milestone where the behaviorist said we can start to take barriers down and begin with a "cat party". Essentially our living room was filled with their favorite things in hopes they would pay more attention to those things instead of each other.

Initially, it went well with both cats eating from the same plate without issues. However, it quickly escalated into fights, which we managed to redirect with treats and toys, only for another fight to start minutes after until eventually our behaviorist said to break it up and put the kitten back into his room.

Although the behaviorist said he's seen worse interactions with cats that are now friends, he suggested harness training to control the kitten's pouncing in future interactions but didn't offer clear next steps. We've exhausted all recommended methods, yet there's seemingly little improvement in their dynamic. This feels like a last resort, leaving us feeling quite hopeless. I would do anything to keep this kitten but it's hard to see the light at the end of the tunnel.

Kitten's Adjustment
Outside of interactions with our resident cat, the kitten is constantly happy, playful, and curious, adjusting well to our home.

Current Setup
We've confined the kitten to our small guest room to manage interactions. Swapping their locations offers some relief and ability for him to get his ya-ya's out, but neither cat enjoys the guest room, and the constant management is exhausting for us. We also use pheromone diffusers and collars.

Our Concerns:
  1. Are we at the point where rehoming might be the best option for everyone's well-being?
  2. How do you know when you've given it enough time?
What We Want
Ideally, we'd love to keep him; we love him dearly and don't want to lose him. However, we're seeking advice. We want him to have a home where he can roam freely without causing stress to another cat.

I'd appreciate any advice, or suggestions on any additional strategies we might not have tried.
 

doomsdave

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 2, 2016
Messages
7,418
Purraise
10,343
Location
California
leealandennis leealandennis nice to meet you and welcome to TCS!

It’s good you care about both your kitties enough to want to do what’s best for both.

Young male kitties are often much more problematic behavior-wise than similarly situated girls, like their human counterparts. (And how do I know that? :dazzler:)

As your energy burning boy gets older he will mellow out a lot, at least in my experience. And he’ll be wuvable too!

This is Conan aka Shifferbrains who I got in summer 2019 as a pretty over energized kitten of six months. It’s been a few years and he’s definitely an adult.

He definitely gets along MUCH better with my elderly male and almost there female than he used to.

843B697A-D972-4E55-A631-70CE201CC66C.jpeg
 

Kris107

Cat mom, cat foster mom
Staff Member
Forum Helper
Joined
Mar 6, 2023
Messages
1,515
Purraise
3,382
The cat party seems strange to me. Sometimes too much stimulation can make cats more wacky. You have to help the young one learn manners. Do short visits. Do they have a cat tree? Sometimes vertical space can help. Like doomsdave doomsdave said, he will likely calm down as he gets older but I know that feels like a long time.
 

Margot Lane

Kitten at heart, not a Top Cat
Top Cat
Joined
Oct 24, 2021
Messages
5,304
Purraise
11,294
:yeah: Agreed. If you really, really want to keep the kitten, wait it out. Remember how much energy you had as a kid? It’s that. He needs to burn it out and the best medicine is patience…and yeah, maybe lots of cat trees. There are even cat wall shelves you can get…maybe a super high one would give your elder cat some space.
 

doomsdave

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Dec 2, 2016
Messages
7,418
Purraise
10,343
Location
California
To concur with K Kris107 and Margot Lane Margot Lane and elaborate a bit, kitties aren’t social beings like people and dogs. What generally passes for socializing among cats is pretty much tolerance of proximity.

leealandennis leealandennis your kitties likely won’t come to bond in love (though it does happen!) and will generally just grow more willing over time to sit or lay near each other, maybe on the same windowsill or on nearby cushions on the same sofa. Or take turns eating or drinking from the same dish. When they get old they’ll often be too tired or sore to fight or quarrel.

If your home is big enough to allow some space that will help a lot. Also, so will keeping the litter box, on the one hand, and food and water on the other, on opposite sides of your home if that’s practical.
 
Top