Although I am hesitant to feed dry my cats are doing very well on the farmina wild boar and apple formula. While the carbs is 19% on a dry matter basis, the protein is 48% and the fat is 18%. I think 98% of the protein is from animal sources. Sweet potatoes seems to be the binder. I’ve been giving lickable treats to try and increase water intake as well as having bought a fountain. Catfooddb gives it 8 paws. The food also contains a lot of prebiotics and they’re doing so well on it I’m elated to see their shiny coats. Either way, every cat is different, yet farmina seems to be a decent choice. Just wanted to share my experience.