Diet time for Daisy

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
I took her to the vet today to talk about getting her weight down. She’s over 5kg at present, or about 20% overweight - the vet recommended she be about 4kg, which is what I’d been thinking would probably be her ideal weight. Now of course the trick is to get her changed gradually to all wet food. The maddening thing is that she’s gained weight regardless of what food she’s on - Hill’s Perfect Weight and Macrobiotic did no good at all, and no, I wasn’t free feeding her and yes, I was trying to get her on the recommended amount for her size, but she just screamed for food all day. She’s been on Fussy Cat for a while, but the vet said grain free foods have been associated with enlarged heart issues, so I’ll be getting her off that! The vet said any wet food that is labelled as 100% complete balanced diet will do. The main problem with her eating wet food is that Miss Social Eater wants me to be right there while she eats, or she comes out to see what I’m doing, and then Phoebe pinches her food. Which wouldn’t be such a problem except Phoebes is supposed to stick to her king’s-ransom anallergenic food!
Oh and the vet suggested adding zucchini to her food. Let’s see if she likes it. She‘ll be the only one in the household I cook from scratch for if she does!

Ransom Daisy pic, just because:

42355AC0-68C8-46A2-9BBC-50361438FED8.jpeg
 

maggie101

3 cats
Top Cat
Joined
Apr 20, 2014
Messages
8,086
Purraise
10,259
Location
Houston,TX
My friend had her cat on Hill's science diet. She gained weight and is now diabetic. My cat Peaches is very healthy,10 yrs old,7 pds wet only her whole life. Grain free causing heart issues I have never heard of. She eats mostly nutro perfect portions, farmina,and wellness
I found this article
Will Grain-Free Cat Food Cause Heart Problems?
 
Last edited:
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #3

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
Interesting! It’s maddening, isn’t it - so much contradictory advice out there regarding cat food. Not that I mind getting her off Fussy Cat anyway, it’s not great stuff apparently.

I’m so sorry your friend’s cat is diabetic now.
 

maggie101

3 cats
Top Cat
Joined
Apr 20, 2014
Messages
8,086
Purraise
10,259
Location
Houston,TX
Interesting! It’s maddening, isn’t it - so much contradictory advice out there regarding cat food. Not that I mind getting her off Fussy Cat anyway, it’s not great stuff apparently.

I’m so sorry your friend’s cat is diabetic now.
I'm not sure what her cat is eating now but she has lost weight
 

daftcat75

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 7, 2018
Messages
12,825
Purraise
25,430
Grain-free isn't an issue with cat food like it is with dog food. Grain-free with cat food usually means they simply replaced a grain with a starch. In most cases, it doesn't actually mean anything. What you really want is carb-free. But that isn't something that gets advertised often--especially when nearly every food contains some small amount of carbs usually in the form of a gum or binder--or fiber. In any case, find yourself a dry matter calculator like this one. You want carbs to be below 30% on a dry-matter basis.

Betty is a nearly identical gray and white "Garfield." (She eats and sleeps and that's about it.) She's also pushing 5 kilos. Personally, I like her right where she is at about 4.7 (10.5 lbs.) Maybe 4.5 would be okay. 4 kg would be 9 lbs. That's what the vet would like. But that looked and felt too skinny to me. In any case, besides a small calories reduction (no more than 15% reduction at a time--forgot to ask what the interval was), her doc has forbidden me from making any other changes until after her dental exam next month that got pushed back from January because of her gut issues. (Oof! This cat's first year with me has been a doozy!) In Betty's case, I strongly suspect we won't be able to get her weight under control until we can circle back to her gut and reduce her prednisilone (steroids) dose once more and/or try her on a lower carb food. She loves the carb-heavy Hills I/D chicken stew.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #6

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
Four kg would probably be right for Daisy. She’s a small-framed cat, and weighed a bit over 3kg when I adopted her - too thin imo.

Yes, it’s certainly her carbs that need to come down. Hopefully a wet food diet will take care of most of that, and I’ll be interested to see if she takes to having zucchini to pad her meals a bit without adding carbs.

She’s definitely a Garfield, this one! She’ll get the zoomies at night and the pair of them will chase each other around under my bed, or she’ll go bonkers with a ball of wool, but she’s not remotely interested in playing with wand toys or laser pointers. She spends the majority of her time asleep on my bed, with intervals to eat or demand that I come and lie on the bed with her.
 

lisahe

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
6,201
Purraise
5,057
Location
Maine
Lowering/limiting carbs is definitely the most important thing. I might also suggest feeding your cats in separate rooms, with a closed door between them, to help prevent one pinching the other's meal. We also feed lots of small meals a day because one of our cats has very bad food insecurity. Personally, I'd forgo the zucchini since it's not a natural part of a cat's diet and doesn't add anything but watery bulk. Adding a little water to canned foods can achieve some of the same goal. In the end, though, we find that caloric foods are more satiating so the cats can eat less of them and go longer between meals than with lighter fare.

In any case, good luck, weight loss for cats is not easy!
 

Alldara

TCS Member
Staff Member
Forum Helper
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
5,903
Purraise
10,216
Location
Canada
My friend had her cat on Hill's science diet. She gained weight and is now diabetic. My cat Peaches is very healthy,10 yrs old,7 pds wet only her whole life. Grain free causing heart issues I have never heard of. She eats mostly nutro perfect portions, farmina,and wellness
I found this article
Will Grain-Free Cat Food Cause Heart Problems?
The phenomenon was found in dogs. I don't believe it's conclusive yet in cats.
 

Alldara

TCS Member
Staff Member
Forum Helper
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
5,903
Purraise
10,216
Location
Canada
I had a good time moving to "grain free" for Nobel. Usually it means rice instead, but I think the wheat and oats were causing him to gain a ton of weight.

He's been good on Purina Pro Plan and Iams perfect portions. Those dont seem to cause any weight gain even though he's less active in his older age.

For dry he has Purina Pro Plan urinary, which the younger boys won't eat, so it can stay put for his grazing..I had to slowly move him to a wet diet as he hunger strikes.
 

lisahe

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
6,201
Purraise
5,057
Location
Maine
The phenomenon was found in dogs. I don't believe it's conclusive yet in cats.
Yes to what you say about cats.

Also, the last I've seen on this whole topic is that potatoes and legumes in certain grain free foods may be causing the problem. Here's an old article on the topic. Canine heart disease may relate to legumes, potatoes | American Veterinary Medical Association (avma.org)

In the absence of real evidence of what was causing the problem, it feels like there are still a lot of vets recommending against grain free as a sort of default position, without taking a careful look at ingredients.
 

Alldara

TCS Member
Staff Member
Forum Helper
Joined
Apr 29, 2022
Messages
5,903
Purraise
10,216
Location
Canada
Yes to what you say about cats.

Also, the last I've seen on this whole topic is that potatoes and legumes in certain grain free foods may be causing the problem. Here's an old article on the topic. Canine heart disease may relate to legumes, potatoes | American Veterinary Medical Association (avma.org)

In the absence of real evidence of what was causing the problem, it feels like there are still a lot of vets recommending against grain free as a sort of default position, without taking a careful look at ingredients.
Yes it is correlation and not causation at this point.

I'll look forward to the causation conclusions later. I doubt we will see mirrored studies for cats, however.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #12

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
Lowering/limiting carbs is definitely the most important thing. I might also suggest feeding your cats in separate rooms, with a closed door between them, to help prevent one pinching the other's meal. We also feed lots of small meals a day because one of our cats has very bad food insecurity. Personally, I'd forgo the zucchini since it's not a natural part of a cat's diet and doesn't add anything but watery bulk. Adding a little water to canned foods can achieve some of the same goal. In the end, though, we find that caloric foods are more satiating so the cats can eat less of them and go longer between meals than with lighter fare.

In any case, good luck, weight loss for cats is not easy!
Thanks! I’ll give the zucchini a go since I just cooked one this morning. I’ve read good results about it. Hopefully she won go back to screaming for more food like she used to on the Perfect Weight.

Unfortunately I can’t separate them when they eat; I’m in a bedsit. The living room is the only place to feed them.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #13

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
In the absence of real evidence of what was causing the problem, it feels like there are still a lot of vets recommending against grain free as a sort of default position, without taking a careful look at ingredients.
That wouldn’t surprise me at all.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #15

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
Amazing the threads you find scrolling through!
I’m stil getting nowhere trying to get her on all wet food. I see Purina have a Pro Plan Weight Loss dry, so I’ve ordered a smallish bag of that. Trick will be to see if she likes it eventually. It’s fish. She likes fish wet food, but not so much dry.
 

Kflowers

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 28, 2018
Messages
5,795
Purraise
7,633
If you buy the 'lean' "mature" and "diet" cat foods check the calorie count, some are over 300 calories a cup. That's almost what the regular food is or even the super active food. A lot of cat foods cut the calories by cutting the protein, that's not going to help.

my cats gained weight on Hill's Science diet Rx for weight management. they maintained on the reduced weight formula. This was some time ago so there is a good chance the company has changed the name of the formulas. Check what's in the stuff, if it's heavy carbs - wet or dry, it's unlikely your cat will lose weight.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #17

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
If you buy the 'lean' "mature" and "diet" cat foods check the calorie count, some are over 300 calories a cup. That's almost what the regular food is or even the super active food. A lot of cat foods cut the calories by cutting the protein, that's not going to help.

my cats gained weight on Hill's Science diet Rx for weight management. they maintained on the reduced weight formula. This was some time ago so there is a good chance the company has changed the name of the formulas. Check what's in the stuff, if it's heavy carbs - wet or dry, it's unlikely your cat will lose weight.
Thanks, I will be doing that. Daisy gained weight on the Hills Perfect Weight and the Metabolic, too. Her vet says she should be on 200 calories a day, which is all very well, but she won’t eat anywhere near enough wet food to reach that, and companies don’t list the calories in their dry food.
 

Kflowers

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 28, 2018
Messages
5,795
Purraise
7,633
Go to Chewy.com and pick out the food -- wet or dry, then in the description of the food click on the nutrition information. At the end of the list of ingredients most give the number of calories per cup. It made all the difference to us to discover that and not have to get in touch with each company. You don't have to buy or sign up with Chewy to read the descriptions of the food.

We ended up getting Blackwood for kitty. Just be sure you buy the one with the same name, picky little name differences. I just ended up buying the dog regular rather than diet in a different brand because I thought they'd changed the package. Regular is 100 calories more a cup. Sigh. Read the name of the food carefully.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #19

catloverfromwayback

Servant to the Ofurlords
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Messages
4,177
Purraise
9,605
Location
Victoria, Australia
Go to Chewy.com and pick out the food -- wet or dry, then in the description of the food click on the nutrition information. At the end of the list of ingredients most give the number of calories per cup. It made all the difference to us to discover that and not have to get in touch with each company. You don't have to buy or sign up with Chewy to read the descriptions of the food.

We ended up getting Blackwood for kitty. Just be sure you buy the one with the same name, picky little name differences. I just ended up buying the dog regular rather than diet in a different brand because I thought they'd changed the package. Regular is 100 calories more a cup. Sigh. Read the name of the food carefully.
Thanks! Would never have occurred to me to look at Chewy, since I’m in Australia and they don’t operate here.

Edit hmm, Chewy don’t sell it. Purina’s site says “low calorie” but no more detail than that. Oh well, it’s hypothetical unless she decides to eat it once it’s delivered.
 
Last edited:

Kflowers

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jul 28, 2018
Messages
5,795
Purraise
7,633
If they won't tell you the number of calories per cup when you call them, tell them, sweetly, that in that case it must be 420 calories per cup and that's more than the vet said they could have. (most of the food run around 386 - 420 a cup, but those are the regular foods.) People are more likely to give you answers when put in a position to correct you than when you just ask a question.
 
Top