A word of advice to cat trappers

Antonio65

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 27, 2017
Messages
6,399
Purraise
10,579
Location
Orbassano - Italy
A few weeks ago I was called by a young woman who had a situation in her neighborhood. A few kittens were in danger and living in the cold and she needed someone who could help her.
She was told I was an experienced trapper so she called me.

To cut it short, one night I went there with my remote controlled cage trap and set it up.
I soon trapped one kitten, transferred him to a carrier and set the trap again for the others. A few minutes later I trapped another kitten (two others went away) and covered the trap with a blanket, as usual.
Then I called the young woman and she took both the carrier and my trap with the blanket to the vet, and I went home.

Later that night she called me and asked whether I withheld some details on the second kitten, whether there was anything I didn't tell her. I asked her to be more explicit and she told me that the second kitten was paralyzed. She said that probably I trapped this kitten while she was still under the trap door and damaged her backbone. I was sure I didn't, because the kitten was eating the bait when I remotely triggered the trap (it's a Havahart trap, it's 30+ inches long, there's no chance that the kitten could be next to the door while she was eating the bait food). Even the vet questioned my words over the phone that night, and again a few days later.

After several days at the clinic, some X-rays, a visit with the neurologist and an MRI, the vets concluded that the kitten broke her neck and she's now paralyzed from her neck down, but I saw her eating, and then running and bouncing in the trap after the door closed, so she was still running and moving when I covered the trap with the blanket.
The woman said she didn't see anything from her observation point a few meters away, she said she has to rely on my words and thinks I covered the trap to hide the incident which she found out later at the clinic.

The vets would like to try and fix the broken neck, but the vet bills will be very high, and this woman says I should be involved in the expenses.

I'm shocked and terribly sorry for the kitten, but I know it's not my fault. I believe that the kitten was so scared that she bounced too much in the trap and broke her neck after I put the blanket on. Anyway, I don't think I will ever trap a cat again in my life.

A word of advice to cat trappers.
Always place and run a camera next to the trap to have video evidence of what you did and what happened during the trapping. I should have
done it this time.
 

catapault

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Oct 5, 2010
Messages
3,873
Purraise
10,380
It is difficult to imagine a kitten flailing around so as to break its neck. While I'm sure this woman is disturbed at what happened to the kitten it is not on you that she should place any blame. Placing blame resolves nothing. Sending you condolences, Antonio65 Antonio65 that your good deed and willingness to help should have boomeranged in this way.
 

DeesCats

TCS Member
Staff Member
Forum Helper
Joined
Jul 21, 2023
Messages
948
Purraise
2,218
Location
Northeast Ohio
Antonio, I am so very sorry that this is happening to you as you did this out of concern for the kittens. I know that you are experienced in trapping cats and kittens because of all the posts you've written and the care you take for the outdoor cats.

I don't in any way fault you for what happened to this kitten. You know that it was fine when you turned it over to the young woman and have no idea what she did in transporting it where it may have become injured.

I am sorry the kitten is injured and requires expensive medical care but I don't think you should be responsible for any of the costs.

It is probably a good idea to use a camera or other video means to record the trapping for anyone that does trapping, especially as a volunteer for other people. Thanks for the tip.
 

fionasmom

Moderator
Staff Member
Moderator
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
15,847
Purraise
21,641
Location
Los Angeles
As the saying goes, "No good deed goes unpunished." I use the same Havahart trap and it would be impossible for the kitten to be near the door when they are eating the bait.

I am sorry that you have been involved in this accusation. Whatever is going on may reflect on the personality or outlook of this young woman who was unknown to you until she approached you for help.

A friend of mine once stopped to take a cat who had just been hit by a car out of the street. The cat died on the sidewalk; however, it had identification and so my friend called the owners to tell them what had happened. They immediately accused him of having hit the cat himself and of trying to shift blame to an anonymous person.
 

catsknowme

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Jan 2, 2005
Messages
11,482
Purraise
6,735
Location
Eastern California,USA
:alright: Please don't give up on trapping! Yes, kittens CAN break their own neck. Back in the mid 2000s, I had a group of feral kittens and during zoomies, one ran into our brick hearth/and-or the wood burner. He injured his neck and he healed but his neck was always a bit twisted. Our vet at the time was an older country vet who simply prescribed kennel rest which the kitten hated. For a long time, he could turn only left and at first, he would stagger when he walked. But he was a happy, affectionate cat who just needed a bit of extra help grooming his back furs.
Anyway, the amount of kitties rescued by your efforts greatly outnumbers one particular accident that likely had nothing to do with you. That's like asking a doctor to never prescribe antibiotics because one of his patients had an allergic reaction to a sulfa or penicillin.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #8

Antonio65

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 27, 2017
Messages
6,399
Purraise
10,579
Location
Orbassano - Italy
It is difficult to imagine a kitten flailing around so as to break its neck. While I'm sure this woman is disturbed at what happened to the kitten it is not on you that she should place any blame. Placing blame resolves nothing. Sending you condolences, Antonio65 Antonio65 that your good deed and willingness to help should have boomeranged in this way.
Thanks a lot, C catapault , this story heavily affected my soul, especially when I learned that the kitten was a little older than we thought. This young woman sent me the images of the x-rays and MRI scan, and also of the kitten's mouth and the teeth she was changing.
This particular image broke my heart! 😭

As for a kitten breaking their own neck running in the cage, I agree with you, but this is the only conclusion I came to. What other explanation there might be?
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #9

Antonio65

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 27, 2017
Messages
6,399
Purraise
10,579
Location
Orbassano - Italy
I don't in any way fault you for what happened to this kitten. You know that it was fine when you turned it over to the young woman and have no idea what she did in transporting it where it may have become injured.
Another person told me that in her opinion the cage might have tipped over in the car during the trip to the clinic, and the kitten might get injured in that accident, though it is hard to believe such an occurence.
I haven't known anything else about the kitten, and honestly I'm scared to ask.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #10

Antonio65

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 27, 2017
Messages
6,399
Purraise
10,579
Location
Orbassano - Italy
A friend of mine once stopped to take a cat who had just been hit by a car out of the street. The cat died on the sidewalk; however, it had identification and so my friend called the owners to tell them what had happened. They immediately accused him of having hit the cat himself and of trying to shift blame to an anonymous person.
The same thing happened to me on the morning of Christmas 2018.
I was driving back home at 9:30 am, and I saw a dead cat on the sidewalk. I stopped the car and went to check on the poor cat, who was cold and covered with frost from the night.
I started ringing the bells of the houses in the street, until a man came out and said it could be his cat. When he saw his cat dead, he tried to accuse me of killing his cat, when it was clear enough that the poor cat had been there for several hours.
That was a very bad Christmas...
 
Last edited:
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #11

Antonio65

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 27, 2017
Messages
6,399
Purraise
10,579
Location
Orbassano - Italy
That all is so awful. If it is not too late, is it possible to suggest to this person that they get a GoFundMe and/or Waggle account up and running, of which you will kindly donate to (that is, if you can)?
Actually I suggested to this person this thing a few times, but she never did anything like that.
I know she handed out the injured kitten to a rescue organization and they were taking care of treatments, vet bills and money collection. This young woman asked me several times to donate, but I didn't like the way she would insist on this.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #12

Antonio65

TCS Member
Thread starter
Top Cat
Joined
Feb 27, 2017
Messages
6,399
Purraise
10,579
Location
Orbassano - Italy
:alright: Please don't give up on trapping! Yes, kittens CAN break their own neck. Back in the mid 2000s, I had a group of feral kittens and during zoomies, one ran into our brick hearth/and-or the wood burner. He injured his neck and he healed but his neck was always a bit twisted. Our vet at the time was an older country vet who simply prescribed kennel rest which the kitten hated. For a long time, he could turn only left and at first, he would stagger when he walked. But he was a happy, affectionate cat who just needed a bit of extra help grooming his back furs.
Anyway, the amount of kitties rescued by your efforts greatly outnumbers one particular accident that likely had nothing to do with you. That's like asking a doctor to never prescribe antibiotics because one of his patients had an allergic reaction to a sulfa or penicillin.
Actually, I had given up before, I promised myself that I would have never trapped again because a few of the cats I had rescued and rehomed or relocated at the shelter died in the following couple of years to sudden and unpredictable diseases. A couple died to cancers, all the others due to sudden anemia (which was extremely weird!), so I thought that leaving cats alone could be the best thing for them.
I've never forgiven myself for interfering in their lives, and I thought that had I left alone in the first place, things could have gone differently.
 

catapault

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Oct 5, 2010
Messages
3,873
Purraise
10,380
If the woman was unfamiliar with trapping, so much so that she was asking around for someone to help her - how experienced would she be at transferring second kitten from trap to carrier. Or was she bringing kitten to vet in your remote operated trap?

There are several too many unknowns in this situation. Good that she wanted to help the kittens. Commendable that you, Antonio65 Antonio65 were willing to help. Even letting her go off with your remote control trap with kitten inside. BTW - have you gotten back all your things - remote control trap, towel, carrier that first kitten transferred into?

But the fault for this injury is not on you.
 
Top