Same here. I got them to eat most of a can but had to mix it with something else. I won't buy it again either. It does seem a lot like FF pates. They don't like those anymore either.I'm glad other people have had good results with it! We think the packaging is cute and we've tried a few boxes of the pate flavor cans. It seems similar to Fancy Feast pate, but not as juicy and the cats don't like it as much. I don't think we'll be buying it again.