Assistance With Starting An All Wet Diet, Please.

Well, to make a long story short, chewy had cancelled my order without giving me any notice and never refunded me. I do know, however, everyone I’ve spoken to that uses chewy has always had great things to say. I think I’ll also give Sheba a look. Is Redbarn or Dave’s any good? I’ve looked at them a few times but I don’t know anything about them really.

Redbarn and Dave's have always been a hit with my cats

I haven't tried Dave's new Cat's Meow line yet, thought I will one day. Mine weren't too thrilled with the original Dave's line.

Redbarn (the lamb flavor) used to be a big hit with Evie and Emerson, but I think they have grown tired of it. Dexter always tries to immediately bury it when I give it to him, so that's a no from him!

I picked up a few brands to try O’malley on. Do any of you have experience with nulo, purina beyond, taste of the wild, whole earth farms, wholehearted, or the wellness pate? Hopefully he likes a few of them since they looked okay and are within budget.

I just started with chewy as they are the same price for FF as Amazon and I get 5% back with ebates. I found 4 crushed cans in my case of food. They contacted me right away and sent out a whole case

I think I finally realized why I have trouble feeding Maggie in the morning only. She must have some miko mixed in! Either buy it or boil a chicken in water

So a little news on the cans I tried...he wants absolutely nothing to do with them. I’ve tried crunching his treats on top but he will just lick that off and then leave the actual food. Any tips or tricks to get him even slightly interested?

Parmesan cheese. I can get mine to eat just about anything with that kitty crack sprinkled on top. Which varieties did you try?

I don't know if it is available in your country but here Brit seems to be the best at price/quality. They have a few "animal derivatives" but at least no grains or harmful ingredients. They have a few lines I am talking about their highest line, I don't know if the lower ones are any good. More expensive brands like ND are good too but I don't think they are worth the price tag with wet food. (For kibble I only buy premium brands like Orijen)