Gelatinous Food But Less Expensive Than Weruva?

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
My geriatric cat has much difficulty eating food with any texture. She has no difficulty eating Weruva Slide `n' Serve. The instructions say 1 oz per lb of body weight, but that would be 4 pouches a day, which would cost at least $5.50 a day. I cannot afford that. Does anyone know a cheaper food that has the same gelatinous consistency?
Thanks
 

Tobermory

“What greater gift than the love of a cat.”
Staff Member
Moderator
Joined
Dec 13, 2017
Messages
9,220
Purraise
26,181
Location
Pacific NW
Someone can correct me if I’m wrong, but that seems really excessive. In my experience, the feeding directions on commercial food often overestimate what a cat should eat. I just looked at one of the Weruva Slide ‘n’ Serve pouches on Chewy, and it said the pouch was 5.5 oz. and 172 calories. It depends on the cat, but in general, a healthy indoor-only cat should have approximately 20 calories per pound a day. So a 10-pound cat would get about 200 calories a day. The directions on the back of the Weruva pouch seem waaaay off to me!
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #3

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
Thank you for responding so quickly. This is the 2.8 oz pouch. It says it has 47 calories per pouch. My cat is 12 pounds, so 240 calories a day would be almost 5 pouches, which is pretty expensive.
 

cheesycats

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Jan 29, 2017
Messages
549
Purraise
686
Location
Indiana
Pouches are over priced anyway. I’d go to cans. I think weruva has a canned jelly type food. I could be wrong though(look at their bff line. They have 10oz cans in 12 packs).
I know though that soulistic (made by weruva as a cheaper alternative for petco only) has several options in cans. They are the light colorful cans that say in gelee. They are cheaper

Ps: using the words gelee and aspic are going to help you a lot. Those are what those jelly like textures are actually called

Pss: lol also one more thing, your cat is 12 lbs? so if you’d move to something like the bff line in gelee you’d have to feed probably a whole can a day plus some. However it’s a little under 30$ a case. So you’d need about 3 cases a month or 36 cans. Bringing u to under 80$ a month to feed canned in gelee. :)
 
Last edited:

mizzely

TCS Member
Super Cat
Joined
Feb 17, 2017
Messages
1,132
Purraise
1,308
Location
Michigan
What I do for Lydia who also likes those and Tiki Cat Mousse is thin pates with bone broth or kitten formula. You could also add in beef gelatin powder to a pate to get the gelatin texture.
 

LTS3

TCS Member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 29, 2014
Messages
19,209
Purraise
19,695
Location
USA
Try Soulistic. It's made by the same company that makes Weruva. Soulistic is basically the lesser expensive version of Weruva and you can find it at Petco stores.

Will your cat eat pate food? Those are smooth like puree and would also be easy to eat.
 

lisahe

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
6,168
Purraise
5,006
Location
Maine
The jellied Weruva cans that we feed are from the Cats in the Kitchen line. The primary benefit with those in terms of price is that they make larger cans: six ounces and, for a few recipes, ten ounces. Not all the foods are aspic-like, some have more runny jelly.

There is also a BFF slide 'n' serve line (check the pounches here). I bought a couple of those for our cats and they liked the first one. It was basically pate that was more held together in a pancake sort of shape than it would have been if I had scooped it out of a can.

Another thought, babs' slave babs' slave -- will your cat lap up food? If so, there are very soft, smooth pates that might work: the canned pates on that BFF pages are very soft and lappable (our cats really love those and there's a good variety of blends) as are Sheba's pates. Also, some foods can easily be processed in a miniprocessor (a little water helps for some!) to make them easier for a cat to lick up.

cheesycats cheesycats raises a good point about comparing foods! Foods that are calorie-dense are often a better deal because you get more calories for the money, plus if your cat is having difficulty eating, she might not need to eat so much to feel full. If you haven't already had her teeth checked, it's worth doing that -- I remember several members mentioning that difficulty eating was the first indication of dental problems.

Good luck!
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #8

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
Pouches are over priced anyway. I’d go to cans. I think weruva has a canned jelly type food. I could be wrong though(look at their bff line. They have 10oz cans in 12 packs).
I know though that soulistic (made by weruva as a cheaper alternative for petco only) has several options in cans. They are the light colorful cans that say in gelee. They are cheaper

Ps: using the words gelee and aspic are going to help you a lot. Those are what those jelly like textures are actually called

Pss: lol also one more thing, your cat is 12 lbs? so if you’d move to something like the bff line in gelee you’d have to feed probably a whole can a day plus some. However it’s a little under 30$ a case. So you’d need about 3 cases a month or 36 cans. Bringing u to under 80$ a month to feed canned in gelee. :)
Thank you so much for the tip on Soulistic. They are much cheaper! I think I found a canned variety I like on their website: Chicken & Tuna in a Hydrating Puree ("In a hydrating Puree" is what the slide-n-serve pouches call it)
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #9

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
Try Soulistic. It's made by the same company that makes Weruva. Soulistic is basically the lesser expensive version of Weruva and you can find it at Petco stores.

Will your cat eat pate food? Those are smooth like puree and would also be easy to eat.
Thank you for the tip on Soulistic. I do see that its is cheaper!
I wish she could eat Pate. She's eaten that since she was a little kitten. But the texture is a no-go for her.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #10

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
The jellied Weruva cans that we feed are from the Cats in the Kitchen line. The primary benefit with those in terms of price is that they make larger cans: six ounces and, for a few recipes, ten ounces. Not all the foods are aspic-like, some have more runny jelly.

There is also a BFF slide 'n' serve line (check the pounches here). I bought a couple of those for our cats and they liked the first one. It was basically pate that was more held together in a pancake sort of shape than it would have been if I had scooped it out of a can.

Another thought, babs' slave babs' slave -- will your cat lap up food? If so, there are very soft, smooth pates that might work: the canned pates on that BFF pages are very soft and lappable (our cats really love those and there's a good variety of blends) as are Sheba's pates. Also, some foods can easily be processed in a miniprocessor (a little water helps for some!) to make them easier for a cat to lick up.

cheesycats cheesycats raises a good point about comparing foods! Foods that are calorie-dense are often a better deal because you get more calories for the money, plus if your cat is having difficulty eating, she might not need to eat so much to feel full. If you haven't already had her teeth checked, it's worth doing that -- I remember several members mentioning that difficulty eating was the first indication of dental problems.

Good luck!
Thank you so much for the great amount of info you gave me!
I've actually taken her to the vet and he said that her issue are due to overgrown gums caused by inflamed tissue. he says it's not dangerous but it won't get better, and he recommends surgery to take it out. I have been leery of that because she's old (19 years). Her blood panel results were perfect, so no kidney or liver issues. It's just that putting an old cat under scares me a little bit.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #11

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
What I do for Lydia who also likes those and Tiki Cat Mousse is thin pates with bone broth or kitten formula. You could also add in beef gelatin powder to a pate to get the gelatin texture.
Excellent ideas, thank you so much!
 

lisahe

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
6,168
Purraise
5,006
Location
Maine
Thank you so much for the great amount of info you gave me!
I've actually taken her to the vet and he said that her issue are due to overgrown gums caused by inflamed tissue. he says it's not dangerous but it won't get better, and he recommends surgery to take it out. I have been leery of that because she's old (19 years). Her blood panel results were perfect, so no kidney or liver issues. It's just that putting an old cat under scares me a little bit.
Oh my goodness, your cat is amazing to be 19 and still have such good blood test results! Yes, I totally understand your hesitance to have her put under for dental surgery. (Our previous cat lived a long life, too, though she was only about 17, and was never fully diagnosed in her final months because she was so frail.)

I know this may sound crazy but our vet recommends a probiotic that can be sprinkled on a cat's food to (apparently) improve dental health. It's Entero, this stuff. We brush our cats' teeth, which they actually enjoy because the flavored toothpaste is like a treat for them, so we haven't tried Entero but our vet told us she's stopped brushing her cats' teeth and started using Entero instead. Even just feeding a little enzymatic toothpaste (we use CET) without brushing can be of some help. Our cats used to have quite a bit of gingivitis but regular brushing with CET helps a lot. Anyway, just a couple thoughts on that in case your vet hasn't mentioned anything less invasive for your cat -- I'm not sure if either would even help but our vet is so big on dental care that there's always discussion about teeth. :D (Some breeds -- like our Siamese mixes -- are apparently more prone to dental problems making it especially important.)
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #13

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
Oh my goodness, your cat is amazing to be 19 and still have such good blood test results! Yes, I totally understand your hesitance to have her put under for dental surgery. (Our previous cat lived a long life, too, though she was only about 17, and was never fully diagnosed in her final months because she was so frail.)

I know this may sound crazy but our vet recommends a probiotic that can be sprinkled on a cat's food to (apparently) improve dental health. It's Entero, this stuff. We brush our cats' teeth, which they actually enjoy because the flavored toothpaste is like a treat for them, so we haven't tried Entero but our vet told us she's stopped brushing her cats' teeth and started using Entero instead. Even just feeding a little enzymatic toothpaste (we use CET) without brushing can be of some help. Our cats used to have quite a bit of gingivitis but regular brushing with CET helps a lot. Anyway, just a couple thoughts on that in case your vet hasn't mentioned anything less invasive for your cat -- I'm not sure if either would even help but our vet is so big on dental care that there's always discussion about teeth. :D (Some breeds -- like our Siamese mixes -- are apparently more prone to dental problems making it especially important.)
Yes, I thank God Babbette is still very healthy. I do think she's deaf, but I treat her accordingly and she does well with it. A previous cat, Stubbs, lived to 19 and only had one bad day (her last), which was crazy because she was indoor-outdoor. Babbette has been indoor only for the last 12 years, as are her relatively new house-mates Watch Kitty (12 years) and WK's boy, Buddy (16 months).
The Entero and C.E.T. read like they're amazing. I wish I could afford Entero, but C.E.T seems great as well, so I think I will try that.
Thank you for the tips!
 

ailish

TCS Member
Alpha Cat
Joined
Nov 7, 2016
Messages
485
Purraise
485
Someone can correct me if I’m wrong, but that seems really excessive. In my experience, the feeding directions on commercial food often overestimate what a cat should eat. I just looked at one of the Weruva Slide ‘n’ Serve pouches on Chewy, and it said the pouch was 5.5 oz. and 172 calories. It depends on the cat, but in general, a healthy indoor-only cat should have approximately 20 calories per pound a day. So a 10-pound cat would get about 200 calories a day. The directions on the back of the Weruva pouch seem waaaay off to me!
My cat goes between 8-9 pounds, which is vet approved for her. She's fairly active for indoors. I shoot for 160 calories a day and she has maintained that weight for two years now. When I read the suggested amounts on cat food cans it just boggles my mind that anyone would feed their cat that much. Ailish would be a fuzzy black whale. If she'd even eat that much, which I doubt. I don't know what the thinking is. Well, I kinda do, but it's kinda not right if you ask me.
 

Tobermory

“What greater gift than the love of a cat.”
Staff Member
Moderator
Joined
Dec 13, 2017
Messages
9,220
Purraise
26,181
Location
Pacific NW
My cat goes between 8-9 pounds, which is vet approved for her. She's fairly active for indoors. I shoot for 160 calories a day and she has maintained that weight for two years now. When I read the suggested amounts on cat food cans it just boggles my mind that anyone would feed their cat that much. Ailish would be a fuzzy black whale. If she'd even eat that much, which I doubt. I don't know what the thinking is. Well, I kinda do, but it's kinda not right if you ask me.
Ditto for me. I have to manage Lily's weight carefully, or she'll go back to being the Goodyear blimp she was at 14 pounds when the vet gently but plainly suggested I begin to bring her weight down if I didn't want all kinds of health problems. She gets about 4.5 ounces a day or less than 200 calories. She weighs about 10.5 pounds now which is good for her. The other two get about four ounces a day. Just to be clear, though, I make their food now so it's high protein, moderate fat and no carbs.
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #16

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
Our previous cat lived a long life, too, though she was only about 17, and was never fully diagnosed in her final months because she was so frail.
So she was well until a few months before passing on? I think that's very good for elder cats and humans, right?
 

lisahe

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
6,168
Purraise
5,006
Location
Maine
Yes, I thank God Babbette is still very healthy. I do think she's deaf, but I treat her accordingly and she does well with it. A previous cat, Stubbs, lived to 19 and only had one bad day (her last), which was crazy because she was indoor-outdoor. Babbette has been indoor only for the last 12 years, as are her relatively new house-mates Watch Kitty (12 years) and WK's boy, Buddy (16 months).
The Entero and C.E.T. read like they're amazing. I wish I could afford Entero, but C.E.T seems great as well, so I think I will try that.
Thank you for the tips!
You have quite the brood of cats! Is Babbette the cat in your avatar photo?

Yes, Entero is not cheap, which gives me pause on trying it, too. I may still give it a go, though -- apparently you don't need much so it lasts a long time -- because it's supposed to be good for the GI tract, too. By the way, if you get CET toothpaste, the seafood is lighter in texture than the poultry, which is a little thicker and gloppier. One of our cats prefers seafood, the other prefers poulty, doesn't it figure?

So she was well until a few months before passing on? I think that's very good for elder cats and humans, right?
She hadn't been especially healthy for some time: Brooksie had quite a few ailments over the years, including arthritis and a very bad arrhythmia, that the vet said meant she might just not wake up some day. (!) The worst thing, though, was that she had digestive problems for much of her life but they were never properly diagnosed. Online resources were much more limited when she first had symptoms so I couldn't get the advice when her problems started that I could get in her last months of life. And, unfortunately, the practice where we took her really had more experience with dogs; we take our current cats to an all-cat vet! She also developed mild cases of kidney and thyroid diseases later in life, so she had a lot going on! Even so, if the estimate from shelter was correct, she lived to be at least 17 and one of her vets thought that was probably an underestimate. Best of all, she was still getting into mischief even in her last days. :devilish: She was a great cat!
 
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #18

babs' slave

TCS Member
Thread starter
Adult Cat
Joined
Sep 10, 2011
Messages
159
Purraise
163
Location
Texas
You have quite the brood of cats! Is Babbette the cat in your avatar photo?
Yes, that's her. She's such a good-natured cat. In her 19 years with us, she has had 5 feline housemates - Stubbs, Bubba, PJ (all passed away) and her current 2, Watch Kitty and Buddy. She's a survivor.

Yes, Entero is not cheap, which gives me pause on trying it, too. I may still give it a go, though -- apparently you don't need much so it lasts a long time -- because it's supposed to be good for the GI tract, too.
For Babbette, I could afford it since it lasts so long, but not for the other 2.

By the way, if you get CET toothpaste, the seafood is lighter in texture than the poultry, which is a little thicker and gloppier.
Thanks for the tip. Babs would need the lighter texture for sure.

One of our cats prefers seafood, the other prefers poulty, doesn't it figure?
Yes, it does. Just like 2 of my cats cats like Tomlin Hairball, but Watch Kitty, I have to spread it on her leg and she has to lick it off.


She hadn't been especially healthy for some time: Brooksie had quite a few ailments over the years, including arthritis and a very bad arrhythmia, that the vet said meant she might just not wake up some day. (!)
Were you hoping that when it was her time, that's how it would be? I always pray that's how my cats would go. Peaceful for them.

The worst thing, though, was that she had digestive problems for much of her life but they were never properly diagnosed. Online resources were much more limited when she first had symptoms so I couldn't get the advice when her problems started that I could get in her last months of life. And, unfortunately, the practice where we took her really had more experience with dogs; we take our current cats to an all-cat vet! She also developed mild cases of kidney and thyroid diseases later in life, so she had a lot going on! Even so, if the estimate from shelter was correct, she lived to be at least 17 and one of her vets thought that was probably an underestimate. Best of all, she was still getting into mischief even in her last days. :devilish: She was a great cat!
Kittens are great and fun, but there's something to be said for caring for an old sick cat. It's very difficult and costly, but rewarding. It certainly teaches a lot about love, life and patience, doesn't it?
 

lisahe

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Mar 23, 2014
Messages
6,168
Purraise
5,006
Location
Maine
Babbette looks like quite a cat with that sassy tilt to her head! She looks very sweet.

Were you hoping that when it was her time, that's how it would be? I always pray that's how my cats would go. Peaceful for them.
...
Kittens are great and fun, but there's something to be said for caring for an old sick cat. It's very difficult and costly, but rewarding. It certainly teaches a lot about love, life and patience, doesn't it?
Yes, in some ways I wish that had been what happened. Though in other ways I'm glad we had the last months/weeks/days, when she was still appreciative of attention. It was hard to know what was right because she was so obviously very sick and sometimes barely ate... but yet even on her last morning, she crawled through the child gate we'd installed at the top of the stairs so she could go down and get up on my husband's desk. That same day, the vet could feel a mass and she said Brooksie's organs were shutting down. We knew that, at least in some intuitive way, but needed to hear it at the clinic.

I think middle-aged cats are my favorite! Our cats are about six now and it's a perfect age: they're still very active and playful but they're not always getting into the trouble they were when they were kittens. (We adopted them at ten months.) They take a fair bit of tending because they have sensitive little stomachs and that's not easy, but it's certainly very rewarding when we figure things out so they'll eat better. The lessons about love, life, and patience -- not to mention feline nutrition! -- that we learned with Brooksie have come in very handy. To be honest, I don't know how we'd be feeding these two if I hadn't done all the reading I did in Brooksie's final months. I feel like it's her legacy. And if she hadn't been such a great cat, there's no way I would have insisted on going to the shelter two days later to adopt a new cat or two: I couldn't stand not having a cat in the house and knew the shelter was always full. These cats (Siamese mixes) were new and got lots of inquiries but they'd been pegged as "quiet cats" for a house without kids or noise and not many people qualified for that! We were lucky to find them! :catrub:

Anyway, here's hoping Babbette likes some of the foods you try out on her -- just ask if you want more suggestions!
 

daftcat75

TCS Member
Top Cat
Joined
Sep 7, 2018
Messages
12,679
Purraise
25,197
You can take a pate and whip it in a blender. If you have a pate that has that jelly stuff on top, that will help it blend to a real smooth texture like the Slide n Serve. You can use bone broth or water to make it thinner or gelatin to make it thicker.

My Krista is still a texture snob, and can't be fooled like that. But maybe Babbette will be more forgiving.
 
Top