When And How To Switch To A New Type Of Litter

Cat litter preference can be as unique as your cat's predilection for specific food flavors or types of scratching surfaces. Switching to a new type or brand of kitty litter can hugely affect your cat's life, so make sure you only do it if you have to, and then do it right.

Take Your Time Making the Decision

Your cat isn't looking for an adventure. Most cats are set in their ways and prefer not to try new stuff, whether it's new food or new litter. For cats and humans alike, change often means stress. You can read more about stress in our article Potential Stressors in Cats - The Ultimate Checklist.

If your cat is happily using her litter-box with the existing type of litter, you shouldn't tempt fate by trying to switch litter unless you have a very good reason. Make an undesired change too fast and you could end up with litter-box avoidance, a situation that can quickly turn into a habit that's hard to break, even if you go back to the old type of litter.

Why Switch to a New Brand of Cat Litter?

Reasons for making the switch could include:

See this Non-Clumping Clay Cat Litter on Amazon.

See this Premium Clumping Cat Litter on Amazon.

  • Your existing brand becomes unavailable (if possible, stock up before that happens, to help you make the switch properly).

Do not switch to a new brand of litter simply because you feel like it. A nice commercial or cute packaging may appeal to you, but probably not to your cat. Also, do not switch to scented litter just because the box smells bad. Deal with the problem by increasing the frequency of scooping and by looking into possible changes in your cat's diet.

Get It Right the First Time

Once you've made your mind up to switch to a different brand of litter, take the time to learn about the various types and see what you think would be the best choice for your cat. Read our article about Choosing the Right Kind of Litter, check our Cat Litter Reviews section, and by all means, start a thread in the Cat Care forum, asking for advice. You want to make the best possible decision so that you won't have to switch yet again a few months down the road.

How to Switch to a New Brand of Cat Litter

So, you've made up your mind and it's time to switch Kitty to a new type of litter. You've researched everything and decided on which kind of new litter to try. What's next?

Keep Stress In Mind

Remember, change is stress. Depending on your cat's temperament and sensitivity to stressors, this could be a stressful process for her. In order to reduce stress and avoid the associated repercussions -

  1. Make the process as gradual and gentle as possible (see methods detailed below).
  2. Try to reduce stress in other areas of your cat's life, or at least to make sure there are no additional big changes taking place at the same time. Consult our Potential Stressors in Cats - The Ultimate Checklist to try and assess if there might be other causes of stress and which could be alleviated.

Change the litter gradually

The last thing you want to do is simply dump the old litter, fill up the box with the new brand, and voila! Kitty has a new brand of cat litter!

While some cats may actually manage such an abrupt shift, most will be stressed out and some will avoid the new kind of litter altogether, choosing other spots in your home for their bathroom business.

Instead, make it a gradual change. Gradually add some of the new litter to your litter box every day, replacing the amount you scooped out. Watch your cat's reactions without making a huge deal of her litterbox habits. Don't "ooh and aah" over her using the new litter, just keep things relaxed and as normal as possible.

If you think your cat seems distressed or suspicious of the new litter, slow things down a bit. If the cat seems oblivious to the change, continue to add more of the new type of litter until the box contains only the new brand of litter.

Offer Alternatives

Another way to make this a gradual, non-threatening, change is by offering more than one type of litter. Keep the old box with the brand she's used to, but alongside it offer a separate litter box with the new type of litter.

You will still carry out the process of switching over the litter in the old box gradually and patiently, but offering your cat the new litter as an alternative may just tempt her to try it out on its own. If you find her using the new litter exclusively for a few days in a row, you can consider the switch complete and congratulate yourself on a successful change of litter.

Note: We may get commissions for purchases made through links on this page.

8 comments on “When And How To Switch To A New Type Of Litter

David January 24, 2023
I needed to change kitty litter because a new line of that brand was replacing the original one. One of my kittens goes in the box and starts turning around in circles as though he's chasing someone. What can I do?
Vincent April 18, 2022
I have an older cat, she now won't use the litter box. I have changed brands and have added new roommates to her living space. Should I go back to her old original brand and get everyone back to the same brand as before? Will this solve he nonsense and alternative habits ?
sparkymema August 8, 2018
SuefromTN said:
Ok.. done with the Breeze system! Cat will use it to pee but still poops in random places! I just saw a video that looks amazing for the Kitty Poo Club.. has anyone tried it?
Do you have a topper on your litter box? My bigger cat that weighs about 18 pounds used to have issues with going to the bathroom in his. I later found out when he would try to assume the position he simply wouldn't have enough room with the topper on.
SuefromTN July 31, 2018
Ok.. done with the Breeze system! Cat will use it to pee but still poops in random places! I just saw a video that looks amazing for the Kitty Poo Club.. has anyone tried it?
sparkymema July 26, 2018
My favorite has been natural wood litter, I loved how well it clumped and hid the smell. One small bag must of lasted me about 2 months with 3 cats. The reason why I switched after the two months though was the mess, I would need to vacuum religiously
SuefromTN July 26, 2018
Has anyone had success using the Breeze system by Purina? Our new cat will pee in it just fine. And I love the tray that slides out with pee pads. He will only poop on the beside the box, however. We are at a loss as of what to do. Any ideas would be appreciated!
1 bruce 1 July 12, 2018
I. Miss. Clumping. Litter. But I have yet to find a clumping litter that's asthmatic friendly and does not break the bank for a house of 9 cats and an obsessive owner that dumps boxes, washes them out, and refills with clean litter whether the boxes need it or not =( We've been using a pine litter, non clumping, that's affordable and easy to handle, but with our girls recent allergies we wondered if the pine wasn't causing the issue for her. Now onto wood pellets but we can't find them for less than $15 per 40 pound bag. The pine stuff is $5 for a 40 pound bag??? I must shop around... =(
bootsandamy2 September 3, 2016
Vet suggested changing from clay litter to scoopable litter when my kitty from the pound started urinating on my carpet even though initially she used the clay litter that my older male kitty had always used. Both cats seem to prefer th clumping litter that vet suggested

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *