How To Choose The Right Food For Your Cat

In this guide, we'll address your most important questions about choosing the right food for your cat.

We'll help you understand your cat's unique dietary needs, explore the different types of cat food, and learn how to read and interpret cat food labels.

By the end of this article, you'll have the knowledge and confidence to make the best decisions for your feline friend's nutrition and well-being.

As a cat owner, you want to ensure your feline friend is happy, healthy, and purring with contentment. But with a dizzying array of cat food options lining the shelves of your local pet store, it's easy to feel lost and overwhelmed.

Fear not, for we're here to help you navigate the cat food jungle and discover the perfect feast to keep your furry companion thriving.

Pet food store shelves inside a new market (M.A. Supermarket) opening in Rome, Italy.

So, let's dive into the world of cat nutrition and discover how to keep your feline friend's whiskers twitching with delight!

The Challenge of Choosing the Right Cat Food

With so many brands and types of cat food available, choosing the right food for your cat can be overwhelming. However, providing your cat with a healthy and balanced diet is essential for their overall health and well-being.

When choosing cat food, consider your cat's age, lifestyle, and any specific dietary needs they may have.

Kittens require more calories for growth and development, while senior cats may need a diet that is lower in calories to maintain a healthy weight.

little ginger kitten eats wet food on white wooden background

Additionally, cats with certain health conditions may require a specialized diet prescribed by a veterinarian.

Reading the nutrition label on cat food packaging is crucial in choosing the right food for your cat. Look for high-quality protein sources, such as chicken or fish, as well as essential nutrients like vitamins and minerals. Avoid cat food that contains fillers or artificial preservatives.

By taking the time to choose the right cat food, you can help ensure that your furry friend stays healthy and happy.

SIGN UP FOR THECATSITE'S EMAIL UPDATES >

Understanding Your Cat's Nutritional Needs

Feeding your cat a balanced and nutritious diet is crucial for their overall health and well-being.

Cats are obligate carnivores, which means they require a diet that is high in animal protein. Unlike dogs and humans, cats cannot produce certain essential nutrients on their own and must obtain them from their diet. These nutrients include taurine, arginine, and certain vitamins.

When choosing cat food, it's important to look for a product that meets the nutritional requirements set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO).

The AAFCO sets standards for pet food manufacturers to ensure their products are nutritionally complete and balanced.

Stages of life matter. As mentioned, kittens, for example, require more protein and calories than adult cats, while senior cats may require a diet that is lower in calories and fat to maintain a healthy weight.

Cats with certain health conditions may also require a specialized diet. For example, cats with urinary tract issues may benefit from a diet that is low in magnesium and promotes urinary tract health.

By understanding your cat's nutritional needs and choosing a high-quality, nutritionally complete food, you can help ensure that your feline friend is happy and healthy.

Types of Cat Food

Wet and dry pet food on wooden table, flat lay

There are several types of cat food to consider, each with its own advantages and disadvantages.

Here are the most common types:

Dry Cat Food 

Also known as kibble, dry cat food is a popular option because it is affordable, convenient, and has a long shelf life. However, it can be high in carbohydrates and low in moisture, which can lead to dehydration and urinary tract problems in some cats.

Look for high-quality dry cat food that contains real meat as the first ingredient and avoid brands that use fillers like corn and wheat.

Canned Cat Food

Canned cat food is a moist and flavorful option that can be more appealing to cats than dry food. It is also higher in moisture, which can help prevent urinary tract problems and dehydration. However, it is more expensive and has a shorter shelf life than dry food.

Look for canned cat food that contains high-quality protein sources like real meat and avoid brands that use by-products and fillers.

Semi-Moist Cat Food

Semi-moist cat food is a soft and chewy option that is often marketed as a treat.

However, it is high in sugar and salt, which can lead to health problems like obesity and high blood pressure. It also has a high water content, which can contribute to dental problems.

That's why it's best to avoid feeding your cat semi-moist cat food on a regular basis.

Raw Cat Food

Raw cat food is a controversial option that involves feeding cats a diet of raw meat, bones, and organs.

Proponents of raw cat food claim that it is more natural and nutritious than commercial cat food, but there are also risks associated with feeding cats raw meat, including bacterial infections and nutrient imbalances.

In fact, the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) strongly advises against giving cats and dogs any animal-derived protein that hasn't undergone a pathogen-elimination process. This recommendation aims to protect the health of our pets as well as ourselves from potential illnesses.

If you choose to feed your cat raw food, make sure to consult with a veterinarian and follow proper food safety guidelines.

Dry vs. Wet Cat Food: Which to Choose

The two most common choices when it comes to feeding cats, are wet/canned and dry/kibble.

Canned pet food. Tasty food for dog or cat on white table.

In this section, we will compare these options, discussing the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision for your cat. Remember, feeding a combination of dry and canned is just fine as well!

Wet/Canned Cat Food Pros

  1. Wet cat food has a higher moisture content, which can help prevent dehydration and promote urinary tract health, especially in cats prone to these issues.
  2. Many cats find wet food more appealing due to its aroma and texture, making it an excellent option for picky eaters.
  3. Canned cat food often contains more animal protein compared to dry food, which is essential for cats as obligate carnivores.

Wet/Canned Cat Food Cons

  1. Wet cat food is typically more expensive than dry food, which can be a concern for budget-conscious pet owners.
  2. Once opened, wet food must be refrigerated and consumed within a short period, leading to potential waste if not eaten promptly.

Dry/Kibble Cat Food Pros

  1. Dry cat food is easy to store, has a long shelf life, and can be left out for free-feeding without spoiling.
  2. Kibble is generally more affordable than wet cat food, making it a budget-friendly option for many cat owners.

Dry/Kibble Cat Food Cons

  1. Dry food has a lower moisture content, which may contribute to dehydration or urinary tract issues in some cats, especially if they don't drink enough water.
  2. Dry cat food often contains higher levels of carbohydrates, which can contribute to obesity and related health issues in cats.
  3. Some cats may not find dry food as appetizing as wet food, making it more challenging to feed picky eaters.

When choosing between wet and dry food, consider your cat's preferences and the benefits and drawbacks of each type. Wet food can provide more moisture and protein, while dry food can be more convenient and affordable. Mixing both types can be a good compromise.

To help you out, we've created this comparative table -

Parameter Wet/Canned Cat Food Dry/Kibble Cat Food
Moisture Content High moisture content, promoting urinary tract health and preventing dehydration Lower moisture content may lead to dehydration or urinary tract issues
Nutritional Qualities Typically higher in animal protein, which is essential for cats as obligate carnivores Higher in carbohydrates, which can contribute to obesity and related health issues in cats
Cost Usually more expensive than dry food Generally more affordable than wet cat food
Palatability More appealing aroma and texture, making it an excellent option for picky eaters Some cats may not find dry food as appetizing as wet food, making it more challenging to feed picky eaters.
Convenience Once opened, must be refrigerated and consumed within a short period, leading to potential waste if not eaten promptly. Easy to store, has a long shelf life and can be left out for free-feeding without spoiling.

Reading Cat Food Labels

Reading cat food labels is crucial in selecting the right food for your feline friend.

Ordinary female customer buying dry food for pets in petshop

The labels provide valuable information about the ingredients and nutritional content of the food.

Here are some tips on how to read cat food labels:

Look for a statement of nutritional adequacy

This statement indicates that the food meets the minimum nutritional requirements set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO). Make sure the statement specifies that the food is complete and balanced for your cat's life stage.

Check the ingredients list

Ingredients are listed in descending order by weight. Look for high-quality protein sources, such as chicken or fish, as the first ingredients.

What about by-products?

While it's true that the quality of by-products can vary, when sourced from USDA-inspected facilities and reputable pet food manufacturers, they can offer an ecological, useful, and affordable way to include animal-based protein in your cat's diet.

These by-products are superior to many plant-based fillers that may not provide the necessary nutrients for an obligate carnivore like a cat. By-products in cat food should not be considered inherently bad.

Instead, it's essential to focus on the overall quality and composition of the cat food and choose products from reputable manufacturers to ensure your cat receives a balanced and nutritious diet.

Read more about by-products in cat food

Check the guaranteed analysis

This section lists the minimum and maximum levels of protein, fat, fiber, and moisture in the food. Make sure the levels meet your cat's nutritional needs.

Avoid artificial additives

Artificial colors and flavors may not provide any nutritional benefits for cats and are often added to make the food more visually appealing to the pet owner or to enhance the taste. Some studies suggest that certain artificial additives could potentially cause adverse reactions or health issues in cats, although definitive evidence is limited.

Preservatives, on the other hand, play a crucial role in maintaining the freshness and safety of pet food. However, some artificial preservatives have been linked to health concerns. Natural preservatives, such as vitamin E (tocopherols) or vitamin C (ascorbic acid), can be safer alternatives.

While it is generally advisable to avoid cat foods that contain artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, it's essential to strike a balance between food safety, shelf life, and the nutritional needs of the cat.

Should you look for grain-free cat food?

Grain-free cat food has become increasingly popular among pet owners, driven by concerns over grain allergies and the belief that grains are unnecessary in a cat's diet.

But is grain-free cat food the right choice for your feline companion?

Cats are obligate carnivores, which means their diet should be primarily animal-based protein. However, this doesn't imply that grains are inherently harmful.

In fact, some grains can be a source of essential nutrients like fiber, vitamins, and minerals, contributing to a balanced diet for your cat.

The primary concern with grain-containing cat food arises when grains are used as cheap fillers, displacing high-quality protein sources. The concern is legitimate. However, you should focus on the quality and proportion of ingredients in your cat's food rather than merely seeking a grain-free label.

For some cats with specific food sensitivities or allergies, grain-free cat food might be a suitable option. Just keep in mind that allergies to grains are relatively rare in cats, and protein sources like chicken, beef, or fish are more common allergens.

Choosing the Right Cat Food

Choosing the right cat food is crucial for your cat's health and well-being.

Let's recap some tips -

  • Read the label: The nutrition label on food packaging is the best way to compare cat foods. Look for a food that has a high percentage of animal protein and a low percentage of carbohydrates.
  • Consider your cat's life stage: Cats have different nutritional needs depending on their age and activity level. Look for a food that is specifically formulated for your cat's life stage.
  • Ask your vet: Your veterinarian can provide valuable advice on choosing the right cat food for your pet.
  • Ignore the hype: Pet food manufacturers often make claims about their products, such as "grain-free" or "natural." It's important to read the ingredients list to ensure the food is actually healthy for your cat.

By following these tips, you can make an informed decision when choosing the right cat food for your pet.

Consult with your veterinarian before making significant changes to your cat's diet, especially if your cat has any health issues or is on medication. Your veterinarian can provide personalized recommendations and help you make informed decisions about your cat's nutrition.

With the right food and care, your cat can live a healthy and happy life. Follow the tips and guidelines outlined in this article to ensure that your cat is getting the nutrition they need to thrive.

Comments? Leave them using the form below. Questions? Please use the cat forums for those!

SIGN UP FOR THECATSITE'S EMAIL UPDATES >

We'd like to thank OpenAI's ChatGPT for lending a helping paw in the creation of this article.

Note: We may get commissions for purchases made through links on this page.

21 comments on “How To Choose The Right Food For Your Cat

Elias Jaxon March 21, 2023
Your article is very helpful for me after reading your article I got a lot of information... I read your article carefully thanks for sharing information.
Mary Ann Seidman March 7, 2021
I am trying to find a wet food that my 2 year cat will eat. I have tried so many I lost count. She only eats Purina pro Dry Food. She sometimes throws up if she eats too much too fast, so we can only feed her in little bits through out the day. She doesn't even like people foods like real tuna or salmon, I keep hoping her tastes will mature, I would love to find a wet food she can enjoy. I did also try the "softer" dry food, she won't eat that either, so I have no choice but to feed her dry food. Any ideas on a brand for extremely picky eaters? If it's a brand I haven't tried yet, it might be the one that works!
    Elgatoooooooooo April 20, 2023
    My cat doesnt like much wet food either, and my cat also throws up when he eats too much food too fast! So i know what you feel like, mary.
Abe October 19, 2020
Thhis arficle is truly a nice one it helps new net people, who are wishing for blogging.
Venus July 26, 2020
Marvelous, what a web site it is!This web site provides valuable facts to us, keep it up. site
Cleveland July 12, 2020
I'm impressed, I must say. Rarely do I come across a blog that's both educative and interesting, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. The issue is an issue that not enogh folks arre speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I found this during my hunt for something concerning this.
Clay July 11, 2020
Thanks for the marvelous posting! I ceertainly enjoyed reading it, you are a great author.I will mzke certain to bookmark your blo and will eventually come back later on. I waant to encourage you to definitely continue your great posts, have a nice evening!
Furballsmom June 9, 2019
Lokey said:
Hi to all you cat mom's and Dad's! I'm new here, but I need some help....It's only been a week and over $700.00 later and the only issue was my cat has diabetes, everything else was great! He lost 2lbs in four days and his count went from over 600 to 300, so they did a curve yesterday and increased his insulin and want him to have another curve next week. My problem is this, I live on a fixed income and they prescribed hills diet/weight management wet and dry (Extremely expensive) he will not eat the dry whatsoever and it took him a day and half to eat the wet and prior to his diagnosis he was a leisure eater on dry food. My vet said, he has to eat two cans of it twice a day every 12 hours I have to sit with him an entire hour as he is literally working on eating a half can and I have to fluff it with a fork every couple of minutes so he eats it and as soon as he is done eating that half can I have to give him his insulin. I've mentioned it to my vet and she said, I could put him on a over the counter cat food with low carbs and high protein diet any suggestions because his brother will not eat either as well.
Hi Lokey! As the article suggests, please post your question in the forum Cat Nutrition, here Cat Nutrition. This is where the forum members hang out and they will be able to provide you with advice and support. Thanks!
    Mike June 13, 2021
    I feed mine roasted chicken thighs once a week. At the coast of premium cat food it’s actually cheap. Then some tender centers which they insist on and some friskier beef, the main attraction is the gravy, some 9 lives pate and a day of all they can eat fussie cat tuna, mussels, smoked tuna whatever is at the pet store in stock. I think the chicken is a requirement they do not like it constantly and strangely they like the thighs better than the skinless breasts. The chicken maybe a good idea the Walmart store brand at 1.60$ or so a pound is about the same as the friskies.
Lokey May 30, 2019
Hi to all you cat mom's and Dad's! I'm new here, but I need some help....It's only been a week and over $700.00 later and the only issue was my cat has diabetes, everything else was great! He lost 2lbs in four days and his count went from over 600 to 300, so they did a curve yesterday and increased his insulin and want him to have another curve next week. My problem is this, I live on a fixed income and they prescribed hills diet/weight management wet and dry (Extremely expensive) he will not eat the dry whatsoever and it took him a day and half to eat the wet and prior to his diagnosis he was a leisure eater on dry food. My vet said, he has to eat two cans of it twice a day every 12 hours I have to sit with him an entire hour as he is literally working on eating a half can and I have to fluff it with a fork every couple of minutes so he eats it and as soon as he is done eating that half can I have to give him his insulin. I've mentioned it to my vet and she said, I could put him on a over the counter cat food with low carbs and high protein diet any suggestions because his brother will not eat either as well.
Keedaboo69 August 18, 2018
Hi my first time here. I give my cats blend a cheap brand of cat food. They seem to like it no more than a handful for each. Is this the best kind of food to give them.
novathekittycat January 15, 2016
Very helpful. Thank you. :)
peaches123 December 30, 2014
OK, I'm going crazy... As some of you know my 16 year old cat Peaches is on Hills canned prescription J/D formula because the vet said her teeth are good and thyroid and kidney functions were normal.  I don't have much money as Mommy is on disability herself, so the vet diagnosed her with arthritis in her jaw,and all over I suppose.  The problem is my other cat Zoe can still eat dry food and is quite large, not fat but tall with gigantic 6 toes each on her rear paws. Anyway, no matter how quiet I am she smells the wet foo, (which I always warm up a bit in the microwave) and feed Peaches on a plate next to me on the couch and Zoe tries to angle her way in to eat it, and there's a small dog in the house too.  I can't afford to feed both of them the J/D wet food, it's almost $2.00 a can.  But Peaches gets nervous with the other 2 just waiting for scraps and isn't as much as she should,  Any ideas?
buffy2011 August 18, 2014
Not sure if this is where I should be posting but it pertains to cat feeding so here goes. I have a feral cat which I am taming, coming along OK. When I got the kitten it was 7 months old and I started feeding it Purina kitten food and I would give it some soft fancy feast. Never had a problem. Well it is around 16 months old now and I started it on Natural Balance Original. It is for kittens up to adults. I started mixing the food together with the kitten food at first to make the transition. Now it is on regular Natural Balance. I noticed it started to spit up a little bit on the floor. It wasn't eating the soft food so I thought it didn't like that flavor so I switched it. Now today it spit up the dry food. Is this food to rich for its stomach or should I switch back to the kitten food? Did I take her off it too soon?  I'm trying to get all my cats on the same food. But also have another cat that spits up this Natural Balance. Is there something in it I don't know about? I did feed them Taste of the Wild but my one cat always had a swollen lip so I took her off of it because it had fish it in and put her on Natural Balance. Now she is ok that I know of. But I tried to put them all on Natural Balance and this isn't working.Need some help out there. Thansk
satsumasryummy February 26, 2014
Warming up food is also great because many nutrients (in food) are more bioavailable when they are heated up, at least for humans. If the cat prefers it and there is also a chance of it being more effective nutritionally for them, then warm cat food is the way to go. 
Anne February 2, 2014
@stewball and others, please take any questions you may have to the nutrition forums. Comments are very welcome here, but questions are more likely to be answered in the forums.
debbien627 January 22, 2014
Poor kitty. Glad I found this site. No more cold food
ldg January 2, 2014
Well, warming up the food is just a tip. *Some* cats don't like cold food. When I first started feeding raw, my cats did not like the food right out of the fridge. Now they don't mind. When feeding canned food, a number of people find their cats are fussy about eating leftovers. One way to manage this is to freeze (in a container other than the can) the leftover food in meal-sized portions, thaw and serve.
kookoo4kitties October 18, 2013
I had no idea you weren't supposed to give them cold from the fridge food! So glad I read this!
Anne September 19, 2013
 As carnivores, cats prefer to eat their food warm. I think it's a great topic for our forums, so please do go ahead and start a thread about this in the Health and Nutrition forum - thank you!
gravekandi September 19, 2013
 Why shouldn't you feed your cat cold food?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top